The current attitude of winnie "porters"

liquidplasmaflow, you have my support.

Let the winni "porter" spread the word of the deskmod gods.

Could you imagine Jesus Christ not allowing the Bible to be translated because some words are lost in translation??

I cant

#311878

Could you imagine Jesus Christ not allowing the Bible to be translated because some words are lost in translation??

I cant

What the hell? Jesus Christ didn't write the Bible, for one, nor does he hold any relevant copyrights. Don't introduce unrelated topics, especially ones even loosely tied to religion.

-NC

#311879

Okay, then imagine any book that was written in a language foreign to you; if everybody you knew that understood that language told you that it was an AMAZING book... wouldn't you want to read it? And wouldn't a writer want everyone to read it, regardless of language?

#311880

But if I was the author, and someone did a really lousy translation, that didn't reflect the work I'd put into the book, I wouldn't want my name attached anywhere on it.

#311881

But it does in some way "reflect" the work, even if it isn't perfect.

#311883

But the thing is, your name isn't totally attached :P Someone might say, "WOW! That is a piece of trash. I hope the original looks better than this port :S" He/she looks at the original, and there's the real work. The original is admired, but the port is noted as ugly.

very true.

and offtopic, it wouldnt be a bad translation, it would be a perfect translation, i've never seen a bad translation :cool:

#311884

I still agree with Bz, if you wanna port it you need to get permission. No permission from the Author no Port

#311885

Well... as for bad translations... just look around at some of the foreign users' posts here ;)

#311886

What the hell? Jesus Christ didn't write the Bible, for one, nor does he hold any relevant copyrights. Don't introduce unrelated topics, especially ones even loosely tied to religion.

-NC

Sorry NC, I didnt meant that exactly. My statement sounds funny though. Thanks for pointing it out, now we are two laughing

PS: I am foreign!

#311887

Haha, sorry I reacted so violently (well, not violently...kinda knee-jerk, though)...you have to admit, it was phrased somewhat funnily :D .

[Edit: (I knew you were foreign...it's all good )]

Now, back to the topic at hand...

-NC

P.S: By all means, if anyone wishes, they could attempt to derail this topic and start talking about various cheeses, but I don't know how successful they would be.

#311888

heh, kinda reminds me of Reanchou, sounds so funny 8-), btw bz i hope your not still pissed at me for what i said to you. when i said good job to that kid for arguing with you. i feel stupid :

#311889

Ok ladies.

When Jebus gets drawn into this, it's that time when a thread gets Unbe'd (or whatever it's called)

This matter will be discussed among staff and if i get my way, rippers won't have much to look forward on AS.

_________________________________

/Thread closed

Unbeliever

#311926