[help]dual Cpu's Vs. A Single Cpu

I'm looking into building a PC, but just don't know enough about the nitty gritty details of PC's. :shy:

I was wondering what the benefits of dual CPU's were and which motherboards can have two P4/AMD processors. :mellow:

#108553

Dual cpus realy arnt faster, they just do things faster, if you get my drift. basicaly each CPU can only handle one thread, or 'job'. In most things like games and what not theres one big thread, adn a few little threads, so it doest realy speed up stuff much, because the second cpu is only handling a few little threads, very little cpu power. But in things designed for 2 cpus, or running multible applications at once it blows your mind away. So if a program is optimised for mutlible cpus, it will have like 2 medium sized threads.

Its kinda like having two guys to do things. There are some jobs that arnt made for two people (ie driving a car or baking a cake) and some jobs where two people doubles the speed (ie sorting a huge pile of letters, or moving out of your apartment early because the damn landlord decided to evict you because your too loud and someone put marijuna in your mailbox because hes an idiot and the postperson found it and called the cops)

Theres no motherboard for a dual P4, or a dual Athlon. A cpu has to be designed for dual support, so we have the xeon (intel) and athlons line the AMD MP, or the new operons. The only motherboards that have 2 cpu sockets are server boards. Tyan makes allot of these.

edit: i think intels Itanium is a MP cpu too

#108555

This is an interesting topic.

First, WindowsXP HOME does not support dual CPUs, you will need a dual-cpu capable OS for that. WindowsXP Pro, Windows Server OSs, Linux, BSD, etc will all work.

lostspyder is right that each thread can only run on one processor, but many apps are made specifically to use many threads, so they can span across processors. Photoshop, Maya, and other high end apps do this.

Having a 2 3Ghz CPUs will not equal a 6Ghz CPU, but you will get a big benefit when you multitask, and you will have a lot less lag.

Would I do it? If you have the money, sure. But having lots of RAM is more important. So if you can afford a gig of RAM, and still have cash left over, dual CPU is a way to go.

Important: DONT SKIMP ON THE MOTHERBOARD. Getting a cheap motherboard will degrade the benefits of dual cpus. Get dedicated channels for each cpu, dual channel RAM, etc. You'll have to do research on this.

Having a good multi-proc OS is also important. Windows is really not that great with SMP. For example, Linux can run on over 512 processors, Windows can only do 16 (I think). Linux has wonderful SMP support, and you will get the most out of your dual processors with it, but it requires a lot more time, as you have to learn a new OS.

#108566

Forgive me for asking but why would one care if a OS supports 512 processors when they are bearly going to run 2 at the most and 16 would be overkill? And I'm talking about the average user not a scientist or uber geek.

BTW the limit on windows depends on what edition you use. XP is set to 2, and then if you want more you have to get a server edition. Windows server 2003 can do 64 CPU's.

BeOS on the other hand, can only do 8.

#108574

Originally posted by smoke@Feb 1 2004, 05:01 AM

Forgive me for asking but why would one care if a OS supports 512 processors when they are bearly going to run 2 at the most and 16 would be overkill? And I'm talking about the average user not a scientist or uber geek.

BTW the limit on windows depends on what edition you use. XP is set to 2, and then if you want more you have to get a server edition. Windows server 2003 can do 64 CPU's.

BeOS on the other hand, can only do 8.

well if your in the server business or Super computer business.. 512 Processors would be ideal for your job.

-bolero

#108580

Originally posted by contrasutra@Feb 1 2004, 04:20 AM

Linux has wonderful SMP support

I read that linux is a realy bad multiple cpu support, because of the way the kernel handles tasks, and memorie. In fact the preformance of linux on more then 8 CPUS was way below that of windows. The fact that it can run on so many CPUs it think is beside the point. A system that has more then 4 cpus is considerd a supercomputer, and not in general use at all. I think that microsoft decided to not to program in something this unescary, as far as market share goes.

#108586

Why does 512 CPU capability matter on a 2CPU system? I'll tell you.

The way SMP works is that you can theoretically go up to an unlimited amount of processors once its been implemented, but your performance degrades as you add processors, so if you can add lots of processors and still keep good performance, you're going to perform REALLY well under just a couple CPUs.

Basically, if you can do something well under 64 cpus, you can do something AMAZING on 2. (this is of course assuming you use SMP and not NUMA).

lostspyder: This was under 2.2.

2.4 and 2.6 scale extremely well, though still behind some of the real unices.

#108593

Originally posted by bolero@Jan 31 2004, 10:44 PM

well if your in the server business or Super computer business.. 512 Processors would be ideal for your job.

-bolero

I wasn't talking about someone in that business. I was talking about for the home computer not for a server or supercomputer for a big business.

BTW, are there any benchmarks out that compare the performance of win2k3 and the latest linux kernels on identical hardware with 64 CPU's?

#108625

A few things to add - first of all, Windows Server 2003 DataCenter Edition (the one that Microsoft dont' publicise, and don't let any but their people install) can support up to 256 processors.

As for SMP performance, Linux is better. There's no two ways about it. Don't get me wrong, Windows NT-based OSes are good at SMP, but Linux is stunning. Also, because of the way a lot of Windows programs (not Windows, the apps) have been written (by coders who don't have to worry about their code being scritinised too much), any SMP stuff that has been done in a lot of Windows-only apps (Not Photoshop, Maya, whatever) and non-Pro apps is generally rubbish.

It takes a damn' good coder to understand how to implement a good SMP-enabled system, and the majority of software houses just don't have these sorts of coders.

If you're seriously looking at a dual-CPU machine, I would ask what you intend to do with it... If you're going to be running it as a development environment (like I intend to) or as a "creativity workstation" (video, audio, image), then 2 CPUs and lots of RAM will be brilliant for you. If you're a gamer or don't do much more than mess with your PC, then you won't notice the benifits quite so much... The only time you ever really notice dual CPUs is when you want to do really really intensive tasks at the same time as using your system.

Oh, and one more thing... God Box ;)

#108676

i have a Intel 3.0 Ghz CPU with HT technology in my Notebook and it can handel 2 threads

threads.jpg

#108705

Hyperthreading doesn't actually enable the CPU to do multi-processing.

It's a trick by which Intel can make more efficient use of the pipelines by executing certain instructions in parallel.

In short - HT can be a little better, in certain situations, but most of the time, it's about the same, if not a little slower, than an equivalent uniprocessor.

NB: That's the short desription. I'm happy to break out the page-long one, if anyone feels like arguing -_-

#108715

Here's something I picked up on some board a while ago, it's supposed to be from the HP superdome. Obviously it's not my machine, but since we're talking multiprocessors I thought I'd put it up. (The quality looks like that because it was screencapped from RDP using paint; I think the numbers are clearer if you zoom in.)

superdome.png

#108732

Originally posted by GillBates@Feb 1 2004, 04:30 PM

Here's something I picked up on some board a while ago, it's supposed to be from the HP superdome. [...]

It's not real.

For starters, there's the fact that "HP Superdome is the industry's leading proven high-end UNIX server". To further disprove that screenie, there's the fact that Superdome runs on SPARC, which Windows won't run on...

Someone's been telling you porkie-pies, GillBates.-_-

HP's Superdome Overview

I stand corrected.

HP's Integrity Superdome "can run HP-UX, Windows Server 2003 Datacenter Edition, Linux and OpenVMS is planned for the future."

One would assume, based on that, that prior to Windows 2003, Superdomes ran Windows 2000 Datacenter.

#108733

Steve: Just because you keep mentioning the "God Box" doesn't mean it will show up on your doorstep tomorrow. ;)

Also, I LOVE hyperthreading. I was fixing someones machine who had the 2.6HT, and I had to compile a new kernel for them (this was in linux), and it freaken rocked. The whole system flew, definitely faster than a 2.5 P4. And this was on the 2.4 kernel, which only has hacked up HT support. I was compiling 2.6 so he could get full performance.

PS. Steve must be drunk or dying. Ive never heard such compliments. Maybe he was being facetious?

#108768

Originally posted by contrasutra@Feb 1 2004, 06:26 PM

Steve: Just because you keep mentioning the "God Box" doesn't mean it will show up on your doorstep tomorrow. ;)

Also, I LOVE hyperthreading. I was fixing someones machine who had the 2.6HT, and I had to compile a new kernel for them (this was in linux), and it freaken rocked. The whole system flew, definitely faster than a 2.5 P4. And this was on the 2.4 kernel, which only has hacked up HT support. I was compiling 2.6 so he could get full performance.

PS. Steve must be drunk or dying. Ive never heard such compliments. Maybe he was being facetious?

I can hope, can't I? <_<

As for hyperthreading, I'm not saying it's not good, I'm just saying that it's not a miracle "cure all", like a lot of people seem to think. Compiling, for example, is something that would be improved by HT, because compilation can be broken up into lots of little jobs, which are fairly easy to optimise... Especially when your compilers are as matured as Linux' are.

As for the compliments to linux, why lie? You, of all people, should know that I'm happy to admit Windows has it's flaws, and that *nix has its advantages, it's just that, for me, these advantages are far outweighed by the fact that I know Windows intimately.

I know force of habit shouldn't stop me from switching, but it does.

#108772

Yeah, I know Steve, you are the most open minded MS Zealot I know.

The problem with being a Windows expert and than switching to UNIX is that UNIX lets you do so much more (transparent from top to bottom), so you feel like you're learning to walk again. Very disheartening.

In the end though, it's probably a good thing to learn UNIX if you're "in the business".

Did you know MS uses SUN machines on all their big internal servers? Freaky.

#108773

Originally posted by contrasutra@Feb 1 2004, 06:46 PM

Yeah, I know Steve, you are the most open minded MS Zealot I know.

The problem with being a Windows expert and than switching to UNIX is that UNIX lets you do so much more (transparent from top to bottom), so you feel like you're learning to walk again. Very disheartening.

In the end though, it's probably a good thing to learn UNIX if you're "in the business".

Did you know MS uses SUN machines on all their big internal servers? Freaky.

Exactly.

You know me far too well. :shy:

#108777

Originally posted by contrasutra@Feb 1 2004, 11:46 AM

Yeah, I know Steve, you are the most open minded MS Zealot I know.

The problem with being a Windows expert and than switching to UNIX is that UNIX lets you do so much more (transparent from top to bottom), so you feel like you're learning to walk again. Very disheartening.

In the end though, it's probably a good thing to learn UNIX if you're "in the business".

Did you know MS uses SUN machines on all their big internal servers? Freaky.

I hope you aren't accusing me of being a "closed minded MS Zealot who has 0 experience in linux or unix" just because I'm not always proclaiming how perfect linux is. If you are, then you don't know me all that well.

#108789

Originally posted by smoke@Feb 1 2004, 07:31 PM

I hope you aren't accusing me of being a "closed minded MS Zealot who has 0 experience in linux or unix" just because I'm not always proclaiming how perfect linux is. If you are, then you don't know me all that well.

He wasn't accusing anyone of anything, just commenting on my attitudes.

Don't be so quick to take offence -_-

#108793

well, thanks for all the input! :D

I've pretty much decided that I'd be better off with a single cpu (because of all your opinions), but now I can't decide whether to get an AMD 64 3000 or a P4 2.8GHz w/ 800Mhz FSB and hyper-threading...

but that's a completely different thread :P

#108861

We definitely don't need to discuss AMD vs. Intel :banging:

#108863

Originally posted by Keith@Feb 1 2004, 06:18 PM

We definitely don't need to discuss AMD vs. Intel :banging:

Aint that the truth.

I'd be forced to introduce you to a new type of troll: The Transmeta troll.

"AMD or Intel? TRANSMETA foo' !"

(Its linus' chip company)

miho: If you're using Windows, DONT get a 64bit processor, Windows cant take advantage of it. The 64bit WindowsXP is still in Beta, and wont be out for a long time.

Besides that, if you arent doing something to warrent dual processors, it doesnt warrent a 64bit CPU either.

#108878

Are you reading my mind, or what, Contra?

Oh, and the INMOS Transputer was much cooler than any Transmeta ever could be. It was made in Wales, after all :P

The whole 64Bit thing is why I'm holding off of getting my God Box (that, and the lack of money), even though I've got the 64 bit versions of Windows XP, Server 2003, and Longhorn (all legal, I might add). Not only that, but the .Net Framework doesn't support 64 bit yet <_<

#108889