[question] New External Hd

New, 120gb. Before I load 'er up, any sage words re:

- NTFS or FAT?

- Partition(s)?

- Others?

I'm on XP, non-sp1.

Thanks.

#96583

Go NTFS, having m external (maxtor 160 usb2) in FAT made it lock up very easily and i harldy could recover my stuff from it!!!

My two cents... use option youve been given by xp to use it...

#96585

Definately go with NTFS- it's a much more stable format than FAT.

-godpunk

#96586

Hmm I just bought a Maxtor 120GB External and did it in FAT format, it did lock up a lot of my files that i cant access now, is there anyway of changing the format to NTFS without losing or having to back everything up elsewhere?

#96591

NTFS is definitely more stable, however.... permissions in NTFS are linked to the GUID of the user, not the username (which is pretty logical otherwise you could rename any account to administrator and kick ass on the system), therefore if you make your drive NTFS and then take it to another machine you might have permission issues because the users won't match.

I guess you could take ownership of the files on the new machine and reset permissions but I don't know if it's a desirable course of action to take every time you move your external HD.

[This post is not based on personal experience with external HD's (my Maxtor is using FAT), only on what I know about NTFS; if someone can chime in and provide evidence for or against what I am saying please do. :shy: ]

#96593

Originally posted by Graphic Adam@Jan 7 2004, 01:31 PM

Hmm I just bought a Maxtor 120GB External and did it in FAT format, it did lock up a lot of my files that i cant access now, is there anyway of changing the format to NTFS without losing or having to back everything up elsewhere?

You might want to take a look at this. THis HDD was formatted wit FAT32

#96594

And To rep;ly to gillbates, it is true, now that i got my mac, ntfs is not giving me the option to read and write data to the HDD until i format it on mac filesystem, for panther im just looking a t the drive :6 :rant:

#96595

Originally posted by Seph@Jan 7 2004, 03:39 AM

And To reply to gillbates, it is true, now that i got my mac, ntfs is not giving me the option to read and write data to the HDD until i format it on mac filesystem, for panther im just looking a t the drive  :6  :rant:

You could just keep it connected to your pc (assuming you haven't thrown it out of a Window -- no pun intended), share the drive on the pc and access it from your Mac via SMB, right?

#96599

yes, but the speed is nothing compared to firewire400.

Second, i had this problem sharing it in my pc network, it wouldnt allow any access to it from the network (i think its beacuse of it being connected to a usb and not an internal ide cable)

And no, i havent thrown the ugly monster trough the window (oh how ironic) yet, im trying to sell it hehehe...

I hope you didnt mean pun as in pedo in mexican slang ;)

#96600

Originally posted by Seph+Jan 7 2004, 04:13 AM-->
QUOTE(Seph @ Jan 7 2004, 04:13 AM)
yes, but the speed is nothing compared to firewire400.

I agree, the network is nothing compared to having the disk connected directly to the computer.

Originally posted by Seph@Jan 7 2004, 04:13 AM

Second, i had this problem sharing it in my pc network, it wouldnt allow any access to it from the network (i think its beacuse of it being connected to a usb and not an internal ide cable)

Damn, that's weird I could have sworn it would just access it like it was another drive... I'll check this out tomorrow @work. Also if you're transferring Mac files to the FAT external drive be aware that FAT does not support one of the forks in the files (I think it's the resource fork?) so you might want to zip up the files before transferring them to the FAT-ty volume, I believe this preserves the integrity of the files (can anyone corroborate?).

#96607

I know what you meant, i was just messing about ;) <--Notice this emoticon, My Offtopic friend you should know this!!!

Your constipated emoticon is not pleasing to the eyes LOL

EDIT: i succesfully got the HDD to show up and be an active network resource trough the mac, tough my brothers pc can still not see it or access it, oh joy of macintosh!

And regarding the fat filesystem, ive found that text gets corrupted into little squares >.< (yes the constipatedsmilie is necessary here) and that any file with an (enye, spanish character) or any accent on it will not be transferred into the mac...

#96617

So re: filesystems, NTFS seems the way to go. Actually, I was thinking about your meltdown in particular when I started this thread, Seph. How about partitions? For example, does having a buttload* of music on a separate partition mean faster access than having everything on one fat-ass partition? Finally, Seph has brought up an important issue: how will switching (to Apple) affect the use of this NTFS hard disk? I can't back up 120 gig of data, reformat to Mac file system (which is what exactly?) and copy back, that defeats the whole purpose of this HD purchase. Thanks.

*see Bates, Gill 2003

#96641

Originally posted by ji eun@Jan 7 2004, 01:44 PM

[...]

Finally, Seph has brought up an important issue: how will switching (to Apple) affect the use of this NTFS hard disk?  I can't back up 120 gig of data, reformat to Mac file system (which is what exactly?) and copy back, that defeats the whole purpose of this HD purchase.

[...]

I think that Macs use HFS+, as I recall...

With regards to using NTFS, Apple state that removable media "should be formatted using the FAT32 file system, which is supported by both Mac OS X and Windows." They then state that "Mac OS X also supports the ability to read files from devices that use the NTFS file system format," but mention nothing of writing to NTFS...

Wanna read more?

Windows Compatibility and Mac OS X

#96663

Thanks for the PDF, StevieBM. Can more Win / Mac users like Godpunk confirm (trouble-free) NTFS compatibility? Seph seems to have had a hassle. My previous 20gb disk worked fine with Fat32 (which Apple recommends), but the responses here have made me second-guess doing that with this new drive. I'll wait for some more responses till formatting, and see what turns up at AXP.

#96670

Not so much of a hassle.

This is what it boils down to Ji Eun.

If you are going to use it with windows only (xp) go for NTFS no questions asked.

If you want to ensure compatibility with mac (to still have read and write capabilities) go for FAT32 but keep in mind of its stability issues on windows... dont - for anything in the world - try to defragment it! :lol:

#96680