G4 Vs. P4

My boss is thiking about getting me a 12" powerbook g4 1ghz. how does this compare to the p4 in speen/power? I had a ibook g4 600 mhz and it seemed verry slow. i have a toshiba satellight p4 2.4 and use CorelDraw 11, Photoshop CS, and Macromedia Firewors MX, how big of a drop will i see in useablity in these programs? :blink:

#96003

Please lets not have another PC vs. Mac argument. They never get anywhere.

#96014

Are you kidding, A Pentium 4 would own a ibook G4 :rolleyes:

#96015

Well...

Because of the RISC nature of the G4 (1.0) and the CISC nature of the Pentium 4 (2.4), you may see a slight drop in performance, but my motto:

Macs ( (Y) ) are usually better than PCs ( :rant: ) anyway.

#96016

Sory not meaning to start a wich is better war. :( Just simple speed comparison would be helpfull say g4 1 gig equals p4 500 or whatever. :cry:

#96021

Lemme just say this- I have an 800mhz G3 iBook that can run Photoshop CS just fine. If you make sure to max the RAM in the 12" PB, you should be fine.

-godpunk

#96032

I think probaly the best way to compair is to look at what time the prosesors came out, and compair thoes (as cpus tend to not outdo concurent rivals too badly, A64 and P4EE for example) Plus the fact that its a powerbook (more cache) puts it at about at a 1.3 ibook id say, and about at a 2.2 P4, or a 1.8 XP tbrd (roughly)

#96063

Each processor has it's strengths and weaknesses so forget the comparisons. You should decide which OS you want to use first and foremost.

#96066

[LOF]skinnylegs is right. I use a G4 powermac 800 mhz and a Dell Dimensions 2 ghz P4 (1gb Ram each - DDR on the Dell) in a graphics-intensive environment (Photoshop, Illustarator, Quark, InDesign).

When I was using Mac OS 9.22 on the G4, it seemed slower than the Dell. With OSX 10.3 Panther, the G4 screams past the Dell. There is no comparison. Panther out performs XP.

Get the powerbook.

#96088

A better (closer) comparison might be a p4 against a g5. But from my experiences, a brand new SOA p4 would kick a SOA g4 bootay. But i would still take a g4 powerbook if offered to me.

#96147

Originally posted by Chi Chi Rodriguez@Jan 6 2004, 07:45 AM

But i would still take a g4 powerbook if offered to me.

I'm pretty sure that most of us would.

#96246

http://www.cpuscorecard.com/

Well...this site has not latest G5, but there you can find G4 processor (1.25Ghz) in list.

#97934

Originally posted by AquaKid3D@Jan 6 2004, 02:36 AM

Because of the RISC nature of the G4 (1.0) and the CISC nature of the Pentium 4 (2.4), you may see a slight drop in performance, [...]

That's not right... <_<

Both the G4 and the P4, as well, in fact, as every PPC chip and x86 chip for about the last 5 years (and most other commercially viable chips) have used a combined RISC/CISC architecture - a compact RISC core, with a CISC layer "over the top".

The differences are from perfectly ordinary trade-offs that the designers chose to make.

Yes, the x86 CPUs were originally pure CISC, and the PPC CPUs were originally pure RISC, but you'll find it very difficult to find a pure architecture like that in any recent commercial processors.

Oh, and you can argue 'til you're blue in the face, but if you take the time to investigate the Instruction Set Architectures (another type of ISA - not at all related to old expansion slots), you'll see what I mean.

#97987

Damn why is this topic so popular, can't everybody see that you can't exactly compare the two, if you like macs buy a mac, if you like the beige box buy it for all I care. -_--_-

#98010

Originally posted by nrzero@Jan 10 2004, 02:34 PM

Damn why is this topic so popular, can't everybody see that you can't exactly compare the two, if you like macs buy a mac, if you like the beige box buy it for all I care.  -_-  -_-

This topic is popular because we're members of Aqua-Soft - a community dedicated to Mac OS emulation. The fact that we happen to have lots of members who are Mac owners is just a bonus.

As for using "beige box" as a synonym for "IBM Compatible PCs", I really don't think the "beige box" comparison has really been that relevant for about the last year, if not more - admittedly the typical non-Apple machine isn't as carefully designed as Apple machines, but, in my experience, it's not that easy to find a "beige box", unless you try really hard...

Oh, and there's no need to be so irritable - just because you don't like non-Apple machines, doesn't mean that there's anything at all wrong with them for other people.

I do, however, agree that you can't really compare the two in the way that most people try to. I've had this discussion before, though.

#98040

Don't buy a computer based on "which is faster". "Fast Enough" should be the factor. Maybe a 1.2Ghz P3 is fast enough for your needs. Don't buy just because one gets 110FPS and one gets 108.

Next, you can't compare. A processor is not a simple device. As we all know, clock speed isn't the only factor, and even then, one processor wont ALWAYS be faster. There are different extensions that go into a CPU (Altivec, SSE, etc) that can drastically increase performance if the app uses it.

Not to mention, the motherboard and RAM play a HUGE role. For example, compare an AthlonXP with a 333FSB and DDR RAM to the same Athlon with 100/SDRAM. The one with DDR and the higher FSB will smoke it.

The comparision APPLE gives (so its probably spun) is:

800Mhz G4 == 2.2Ghz P4

So unless you are doing pure number crunching (in which case, you wouldn't buy a P4 or a G4), speed should only be ONE factor. Compare the other features you want as well.

Im closing this because I can tell its going to turn into a flame war, and we've had this discussion a thousand times.

#98070