[help] Which Setup To Buy?

I need some help on deciding what to spend my eighteenth's money on.. I definatly want to buy a soley Mac setup and burn my P2 400MHz box (while obviously screaming with joy ;)).

Here's some info on what I need;

1. A laptop just for chatting, surfing the net, minor graphical work and PHP.

2. A desktop for work (more graphical work), music creation and other stuff.

What I don't want to buy;

1. An eMac (yech :6)

2. A Powerbook (any).

3. A refurb/2nd hand machine.

4. A PC.

Money: £5,000

Here are the two setups that I can't decide on..

Setup 1;

12" iBook (800MHz)

256MB RAM

30GB HD

ATI Mobility Radeon 9200 32MB

AppleCare

£1,047.99

Dual 1.8GHz G5 Powermac

1GB RAM

250GB HDs

ATI Radeon 9600 Pro 64MB

20" Cinema Display

iSight

iPod 20GB

AppleCare

£3,875.03

Setup 2;

12" iBook (800MHz)

680MB RAM

40GB HD

ATI Mobility Radeon 9200 32MB

AirPort Extreme

£1,266.99

20" iMac (1.25GHz)

1GB RAM

60GB HD

GeForce FX 64MB DDR

iSight

iPod 20GB

AppleCare

Norton Antivirus

Soundtrack

320GB LaCie FW400 HD

200GB LaCie FW400 HD

£3,659.00

I'm leaning towards the iMac setup (but may swap the iBook for the Setup 1's specs and buy some extra software).. If you have any other suggestions, I appreciate it!

#83962

Setup 1 seems better in my mind. Rendering graphics with the G5 will be much faster than the imac, but the imac is so sexy. I wish I had this hard decision to make >.<

Also a lot of software that's on a mac that is shareware 9 out of 10 times there's a freeware program that does the same thing.

Edit: btw I voted #2 by accident

#83965

i didn't vote. And i'm too drunk to care. Which leads me to what i'm about to say.

18 is fun. but 21 is better.

on my 21st birthday, I got "mr. hankey" faced, fell down, shipped BOTH my front teeth, and my whole face was a complete raw scar. I then woke up 9am the next day and got on a plane for las vegas. I'll never forget it. Before then I was one of the biggest pot heads you'll ever meet. Now i'm proud to say I'm an alcoholic.

have fun on your 21. "naughty word" your 18. (:

#83966

In England it's legal to drink at 18 instead of 21 (USA etc).. So I've already got "mr. hankey"-faced. :lol:

This year's New-Years party was the best time I got drunk.. Ahh memories. Deleted you need an Alcoholic tag. :lol:

@Shark; Yeah the only problem is if I get a G5 then I'll need a new desk to fit it on.. My current one only has room for my PC monitor, TV and GC. For an old (before my GC) pic click here. (Yes my cat is browsing SpyMac.. No, really he is! Edit: And the second keyboard is for my DreamCast which now R.I.P. under my bed.)

#83971

You could always but the G5 on a table or something the cords that come with the new macs are pretty long. But then again the iMac is sexy.

Cool cat btw

#83973

I'm leaning towards the dual 1.8GHz now.. With the dual processing I shouldn't see any lag while running Fireworks MX 2004, iChat, iTunes and Safari (right?). Plus I guess I can remove the "shelf arm" from my desk to fit the G5 on top or place it under the desk (where my current CPU is).

The iBook should handle what I want it for I guess..

The only other thing that bothers me will be lack of space (no 520GB ext. HDs), but I guess I can buy some once I have some free cash.

The last thing is I won't be able to afford the AE cards in the iBook or G5 (where as I can with setup 2). I guess I'll have to stay wired up.. >.<

#83986

go with a dual 1.8 and an iBook from a setup 2 :D

damn i wish i had that for my bday!

for my 18th i got a bday party and that`s it (from my parents)

sh(if)ty ain`t it :(

and if i had a G5, desk space would be the last thing on my mind :D

#84011

Poor Unbeliever.. :(

I guess I should just revel in the fact that at least I'm getting a choice that some Aqua-Softians would (not literally) die for. ^_^ And the Setup-2 iBook and the G5 would be over budget. >.<

#84017

well i`d go with Setup 1

it`s to die for (literally :D)

Hope u`ll send us the pics :D

PS I think u should try to bump the iBook in Setup 1 to at least 512 RAM (maxing it would be best) u can never hv too much RAM ;)

#84018

If I dump the Applecare for Setup-1's iBook I can afford to bump the RAM to max (680). Sound good?

I just have to wait for bank sending me my money now! *rolls hands with anticipation*

#84022

well i would go with max RAM now, Applecare later (when i hv the money) U hv a 1 yr warranty when u buy iBook and u can always buy Applecare in a yr (i think?)

Just one more thing:

Enjoy using ur beast :D

#84025

You should really try the ibook 12in before you buy one if you havnt, the screen might be tooo small for you, 14in one is good :)

#84034

I'd love to try them both and see which I prefer but alas the nearest Apple reseller is in Manchester (a good 3hr drive now it's coming up to christmas) and I'd have to find the store and it's rather alot of hassle. If I get time, I'll try to but until then I'll have to go with the idea that the screen will be okay for me.

I'm mostly going to be using it for (as said) chatting, video conferencing, surfing the net, listening to music, downloading and other not so heavy things (or as a "lag-free" machine to use when I'm doing some large, RAM-hungry images), which was the main reason I kept the RAM as default since 680MB does seem a bit of overkill..

Anyway thanks for everyone's advice! Uhh.. Does anyone know of any cheap (<£300), stylish glass desks? I was going to order a iGo (here) but since I'm not getting an iMac it's pretty useless to buy one.

#84038

Originally posted by es.xxi@Nov 29 2003, 03:15 PM

I'd love to try them both and see which I prefer but alas the nearest Apple reseller is in Manchester (a good 3hr drive now it's coming up to christmas) and I'd have to find the store and it's rather alot of hassle. If I get time, I'll try to but until then I'll have to go with the idea that the screen will be okay for me.

Don't you have a PC World near you?

They sell (a few) macs... The PC World near me has both 12" and 14" iBooks, as well as the whole gamut of iMacs... Just a shame they don't have PowerBooks or G5s...

#84039

There's one in Preston (quick drive) but they don't have any Macs there.. >.<

Edit: Or at the last few time I've been there.. I could always see if that's different next week.

#84042

I vote for 1. Because I'm a G5 maniac and because iMac isn't as flexible and powerful as G5, I think.

Timan is very right with this 12" thing. It's really small...you'll get :blink: after a week of working with this ;)

#84051

you..got..money..for..your..birthday...

:o

#84061

Originally posted by Taha@Nov 30 2003, 02:14 AM

you..got..money..for..your..birthday...

:o

FIVE THOUSAND POUNDS . . . . . :blink::blink::blink::blink::blink::blink:

edit: get a car, you already have a computer.

#84063

why waste £5000?

One machine with what you need. Keep the change.

I still cannot believe you got that wad for a frigging birthday.

#84132

@ji eun; You call a 400MHz P2 a computer?! :P And you can't get a decent (new) motor for £5k.

@Ludge; Yes but I've always wanted a laptop so I can do some work downstairs/outside etc. I do rather hate having to sit in my room for hours when doing my work. I want to socialize! And, not to sound rude, I have done without for alot of years and it's only in the last six months or so that we've been much better, financially. I've put up with this.. Machine.. For six years. It's never been updated (apart from replacing a blown monitor) and I really do need a new computer otherwise I won't be able to earn money, period. My Mum also realizes that this is more of an investment than a present, I can finally do work and play at the same time.

#84217

i voted 3rd option:

buy the laptop.

take your 'change' and go travelling in south/central america, or the himilayas, or do a vodka drinking trip in russia for 2 or 3 months.

having that much tech. is just taking away from doing better things with your money.

edit: :P

#84294

Originally posted by es.xxi@Nov 30 2003, 07:10 AM

@ji eun; You call a 400MHz P2 a computer?! :P And you can't get a decent (new) motor for £5k.

You're eighteen. Why the hell do you want a new car anyway? Imagine the insurance. Imagine the tax. A second hand Fiesta or Golf is a perfect car for an eighteen year old. Oh, and a 400MHz Pentium II is a computer. It's not a fast computer by today's standards, but it's a computer. Don't forget that your purchase will, four years down the line, look equally aged - would this make it a non computer too? Be a little less condescending - there's people I know for whom a 400MHz Pentium II would be one hell of a step up. Just count your lucky stars that you're able to upgrade.

Anyway. Of the two setups, definitely definitley go for the G5 one. The 20" iMac is beautiful, but the performance is way behind the G5. I hate the G5 case, and I've always wanted an iMac G4, but face facts - for that money, if you've the choice between a Dual 1.8GHz G5 and a single 1.25 GHz G4, I know which I'd go for.

#84341

So I should throw away a few grand on getting a 2nd hand car? I don't want or need a car right now. Sorry for not elaberating on that. I'm quite happy getting a bus or walking to where-ever I need to go. I was rather sarcastic with my computer comment, it has gotten unbareable to use and the RAM for my motherboard is getting more and more expensive as it's getting rarer, so I couldn't afford to upgrade six months or so ago. Yes, a G5 in some years will look old and slow but that can be said of anything. At least a G5 will be able to handle a decent amount of things in that time. I shouldn't need to upgrade for at least four-five years (apart from increase in RAM probubly). Older machines (P2 or even P3 and lower) can't handle modern day applications or games.

I do thank my stars I'm getting a new setup, you don't know how much. A few people don't seem to realize that I can't earn money without a, now, decent computer. Yes this can just about handle some of the stuff I throw at it.. But it can't even handle opening a 1600x1200 image without crashing. Even to do my A.B.S.T. wallpapers I had to close everything else down just to be able to open Fireworks MX. I've had alot of work passed my way that I've had to say "No thanks, I can't do that", mostly due to resources. I'd love to just be able to sit down, open Fireworks and do my work, if I can listen to music or chat while I'm doing it, I'm even more happy.

Sorry for any spelling/grammatical errors, I just woke up and it's 6AM.

#84611

All right Mr. 5,000 pounds, I relent. If I were you I'd go with a Powerbook.

BUT.... argh, (can't help myself.... am a poor student) I would NOT get a desktop but rather pocket the remaining cash. Max out all the features of whatever Powerbook you buy and get a gigantic external drive or two and you'll be set for the next few years in terms of performance and portability. You won't need a G5 or an iMac with such a fly Powerbook, as long as you're not a film person (and even then, there's the 17" Powerbook). Okay, that's it from me. Good luck with your decision, and, er... happy birthday.

#84617

Originally posted by es.xxi@Dec 1 2003, 12:03 AM

I don't want or need a car right now. Sorry for not elaberating on that. I'm quite happy getting a bus or walking to where-ever I need to go.

Amen!! Gas prices, taxes ( <_< ) , insurance! Insurance is out to get your money but is never there when you need the help. It's an endless cycle of knowing rich and powerful people and if not, your $20,000 in debt by the time you graduate college. Not very productive now is it?

#84619