Does Windowfx Shadows Better Than Y'z Shadow ?

Is it better ? Is there an attached shadow (for WindowFX) to the taskbar ?

#70883

I personally think that windowfx shadows look and run better. It does not put a shadow under the taskbar, it does however do object bar. Also it has other cool effects, i dont use any of the others, but they are nonetheless cool ;)

#70892

thread tagged properly,

OlivierMDVY warned.

#70928

Excuse me master, i'm just a young padawan... :rolleyes:

#70931

if you use objectbar, use winfx. Other than that, y'z with addshadow will shadow alot of stuff(qcd, itunes, etc.) that winfx won't. Their are a couple of extra options that are good, though about 80% of them are relatively useless. Also, changing your shadow a bit is easier on the fly with y'z, but winfx is a bit better to fully customize to your likings.

I use winfx everyday now, i like it. oh well.

they really should update it though.

:banging:

#70937

i dont' think yzshadow will not shadow transparent areas or curved corners correctly whereas winfx will. at least the version of yzshadow i'm using does not.

#70951

Originally posted by OlivierMDVY@Oct 29 2003, 11:40 AM

Excuse me master, i'm just a young padawan...  :rolleyes:

a young one with 30 posts.

You've been around, its not your first post you do buddy.

-------------

imo, wfx is way better.

has much more options, features and it covers up the task bar WITHOUT the need of jef's app. Regarding that, add a shadow by jef exclusively support wfx.

Of course wfx, unlike anything else, supports objectbar.

#70964

Originally posted by Goku@Oct 29 2003, 08:56 PM

a add a shadow by jef exclusively support wfx.

dope, i hardly used it, thought i used it with y'z.

oh and the last copy of y'z i used did shadow curved windows properly. You just had to offset the shadows right.

#70967

the shadow is more OS X-ish with wfx.

#70972

Originally posted by realitybath+Oct 29 2003, 01:12 PM-->
QUOTE(realitybath @ Oct 29 2003, 01:12 PM)

#70978

WinFX is hardware.

Y'z Shadow is Software.

No comparision. -_-

I use Y'z Shadow, because its free. :unsure:

#70988

Ok but WindowFX cannot attach a shadow to the taskbar, without that you have the feeling that the others windows are drawn over the taskbar (because the shadows they cast).

#71244

well but the taskbar gets higher priority over other windows so the shadow cast by the taskbar will always be on top of any window which is not the case in osx.

I use winfx but i block winfx shadows on objectbar. then i add a fake shadow to my finder bar on my wallpaper.

#71252

Workaround: instead of put the taskbar at the top of the desktop screen put it at the bottom so you can easily imagine that the shadow is not visible because this one is always cast to the bottom...

#71255

Originally posted by OlivierMDVY@Oct 30 2003, 06:53 AM

Ok but WindowFX cannot attach a shadow to the taskbar, without that you have the feeling that the others windows are drawn over the taskbar (because the shadows they cast).

actually the new version of wfx does shadow the task bar if im not mistaken.

regardless there is "add a shadow" by jef that saves the day.

Although I use OB.

#71293

Originally posted by Goku+Oct 29 2003, 09:28 PM-->
QUOTE(Goku @ Oct 29 2003, 09:28 PM)
Originally posted by realitybath@Oct 29 2003, 01:12 PM

#71362