SongBird VS iTunes??

Which is better, Mozilla SongBird or Apple iTunes??

itunes-8.jpg

songbird-fullsize.jpg

#518581

iTunes all the way dude!

#518584

iTunes, better GUI,performance,and stability :P

#518609

what about resources-wise? Not that im concerned of low memory problems, but is there an app that can handle your music library without using more than 50mb of memory? lol

#518646

I haven't tried on a PC but on a Mac, iTunes all the way. Songbird was a laggy, buggy piece of crap. It's attempt at Coverflow was pathetic, for one.

#518647

On Mac it's iTunes all the way, it's built into the OS perfectly.

If it a PC, I wouldn't touch either, I've tried them both, iTunes is just to bloated, plus all the other stuff you have to included (quicktime, Apple updater etc) is beyond a joke.

SongBird looks nice, however isn't light on resources either, plus who wants/needs a browser built into a media player.

For me it's got to be foobar2000, it's a bit of a pain in the butt to set up, but once you've got it, it's light and fast. I've got about 45gb of a music library, including album art, and the application sit at just over 50k.

If they could get F2K to run to on a Mac there would be a mass exodus from iTunes, but I don't see it happening any time soon.

#518650

I tried all of them and I decided to use Windows Media Player :D

#518660

not really ...!?!?

#518666

i believe you. ive been testing the sounds from WMP and Winamp and WMP has better output, for a reason. I have a pair of JBL speakers and they sound really good and live with WMP, but with Winamp they just sound dead flat. I need to tweak winamp and put any kind of enhancements to make it sound a bit better, yet not better than WMP.

Does iTunes sound better than WMP?

Another thing, WMP is not that bad now, since i think it comes integrated with Vista i guess is the same kind of performance like iTunes on a Mac? any ideas on this?

#518669

iTunes is really tiring machine i think and I like the WMP's taskbar it's enough for being useful to me. And WMP is naturally better integrated to Windows than iTunes.

#518683

What about J Reaver Media Jukebox ? I'm using it to manage my mp3s and transfer to my ipod and usb player.

#519393

Songbird does not even have a f*cking Equalizer, so I will use iTunes furthermore.

Besides this, it uses even more memory than iTunes on my Vista PC (Songbird: ~65MB. iTunes: ~60MB)

#519404

it's hard to imagine anything worse than iTunes. Foobar2k is my player of choice, 7.6GB of music in my playlist, and it's using 9kb of RAM.

#519409

Last time I used iTunes with around 40, 50 GB of music, it was actually quite amazing how much it lagged. Foobar is pretty much the only sane choice (unless your a Winamp person, though Foobar does sound a bit better).

#519422

I have both iTunes and fooBar installed on my machines...

I run iTunes at home because that is where I sync with my iPod and I like it's playlist management.

But, at work I run with foobar. It has such a small memory footprint that I can run it easily with all my development applications...plus there are some beautiful skins out there for it - and it is easy to skin too.

#519488

Loves SongBird. Great addons for it.

#520652

For me iTunes is the best among the rest! I will try some information i got here. Thanks anyway.

#521420

Using iTunes on my macbook and vista desk.. coz i really need the podcasts...:D

i mean i haf diff set of podcasts that i watch on either ones.. and desk is not exactly used all the tym for hardcore stuff.. (its old)

#521760

Both of them, i install songbird and ITunes in my computer. But i usually use ITunes for player.

and maybe i have an IPod so i need for move songs.

#522158

Okay very weird, but iTunes is much laggier and loads much slower on my computer than Songbird.

Although I could resolve this, there are lots of functions in iTunes that I don't need...

#522192

i use itunes. it works fine, and i have no desire to switch. i used 2 use wmplayer, but when i gt my ipod i switched 2 itunes & i like it btr

#522957

Mediamonkey all the way. Bit more ugly (although i have an itunes skin working pretty well), but definitely a winner with the functionality, tagging capabilities and lower memories usage.

screenhunter03feb042342tf3.gif

#522997