Optical Media -- needs protection? Did the UMD get it right?

So here's a thought that came to mind at 3AM. Sony's PSP games run on UMD disks, disks that are essentially little optical disks like CDs or DVDs, but they have something about them. They are protected by a plastic shell so that scratches and other similar damage is minimal.

So I began to think, why does blu-ray or DVD have this?! This is the way optical media should've been, because this way we wouldn't have to worry about the slightest smudge or slightest nick in the data stream. Seriously, who thought of the idea to put all that precious data you just written to a disk at risk for destruction at the hands of mere human hands (or, you know, your 360 controller that's sitting on top of it... face up...)?! All my UMD disks are great... fine and dandy. No scratches, no marks, no scuffs... You get the picture. It's protected.

It also gives the disk this kind of "cartridge" feel to it. It feels secure and not so damned delicate --- you know the feeling, when you just finished burning a Linux ISO you spent 45 minutes downloading, and you handle it like it were the holy grail? Yeah, you do.

So, I thought of a whole new thing right here. keep the formats, keep the disk itself, just make them people-proof! There can easily be a new format introduced like this, because essentially all that's needed is slightly thicker drives. The internals of the drive would be at maximum just modified to fit something a little bigger -- it's simple as that.

Anyone get where I'm driving at? (or why my car is in the front yard?)

#513188

...So I began to think, why does blu-ray or DVD have this?!

well, they doesn't. :P

back in the good ol' days when cd-roms first became available on pc's (yikes! remember installing windows 95 from floppies?), there were a couple of cd-rom drives that were cartridge based. not exactly what you're talking about, though: you took the cd out of the jewel case, put it in a cartridge, then popped that into a front-loading reader.

anyways, a cartridge based system for cd's, dvd's. etc. doesn't make much sense to me. it would bulk up packaging and storage (and cost!) for something that really only gets handled for 5-10 seconds each use.

what spurred this on? did you scratch your jonas brothers cd?

#513206

*facepalm*

Maybe I should stop righting testimonials at 3:30AM.

what spurred this on? did you scratch your jonas brothers cd?

O_O. You need to die a horrible painful death. No, actually, it was my Who CD.

#513212

Haha! Peter likes HSM3!

#513258

thats the kinda schizophrenia worrying that leads to doubling up on condoms... Than again, you listen to the jonas brothers so, you won't have to worry about that.

#513259

wtf is HSM3?

EDIT: oh. f#ck you.

#513271