Vista vs. XP in terms of speed

Here's what my family has;

Pentium 4 2.4ghz

1.25 gb ram

sound blaster live 5.1 sound card

GeForce MX 440 graphics card (64 mb).

I'm thinking of installing vista (mainly because I think my parents would benefit from windows photo gallery, mail etc as they're not very tech savvy)

I know with my graphics card wont run Aero and all that, but thats ok. My main question is 'will it run much slower than XP?'

I've been told that Vista is a bit of a resource hog, but also that if your computer is fast enough then it will actually run faster on vista (because its got more optimising settings running in the background).

#459380

Well, I can already tell you there are no vista drivers for the soundcard, and creative won't release any. I have the same card and making it work in ANY way is a task. Also without aero, Vista is quite less of a hog, since that draws a lot from the system.

It'll work. But it just isn't worth it. It's not THAT easy. It sounds cool with mail and gallery and whatnot, but it's not. After all, it's not a mac yet ;)

#459386

I don' really think, that it is worth it. Instead of buying Vista, why not installing third-party apps like Picasa and Thunderbird?

Vista has got some pretty cool features, but it makes only fun and sense if you have a good PC. I have both, XP and Vista, but I only use Vista to play around with it. I have installed Vista for a good friend of mine and it was much slower than XP. It also depends on your mainboard and the HD.

He has got a Pentium 4 with Hyper Threading and about 2 GHz and 1 GB RAM, but it wasn't much fun. Everything was slow and it took a long time to boot it.

Another important point is the fact that Vista is very expensive. I would use the money to buy a better graphic card and/ord more RAM. Then just tweak your XP a bit and your parents will be satisified. In my opinion, Vista is pretty confusing for people who don't really know something about PC's. All the questions by UAC can annoy them pretty much.

#459388

Vista is what forced me to get a Mac. I've tried Beta 2, RC1, and Ultimate, and I came to the same conclusion: I still can't stand it. I mean, get this: Microsoft actually has dialogs in the display settings (I think) that have a tab. Usually, when tabs are involved, you're switching between at least two or more. I couldn't believe they actually released it like that.

Also: I tried Home Basic on my mom's computer and she had that EXACT SAME video card, and the UI was very sluggish. Might've been the RAM, because she only has a half gig, but still, home basic and never more than 2 windows open at once? Hmmm. Upgraded to a GeForce FX 5200 w/128 mb vram and it definitely picked up, not to mention Aero worked as well. That card WILL cause you grief in Vista though.

#459390

I have no idea why everyones saying its so bad and slow; I was running RC1, RC2, Vista Ultimate on 512 ram, for half a year that was plently. My computer is .6ghz faster but that doesnt make that much of a difference. Take it from personal experiance, you'll be fine and the step up from xp is a really nice change and completly worth it. Nothing ever frooze, nothing ever crashed, I could run big apps like photoshop. Youll be flyin with 1.25 ram,

#459409

I mean, get this: Microsoft actually has dialogs in the display settings (I think) that have a tab. Usually, when tabs are involved, you're switching between at least two or more.

Just to defend Microsoft here, I think they did that for compatibility reasons, so they wouldn't break the third-party extensions of some video card driver supplements (like ATI's Control Center).

#459414

I have to side with Vista this time, because if Speed is what you looking for you can get plenty with Vista with some (or lot of) tweaking. Chuck the Aero, throw away animation effects and disable unrequired services.. you'll get it running pretty fast and much more stable than XP. But, like Peskat said, your soundcard worries me... in fact these days every hardware by Creative worries me :D

#459418

gotta tell you this:

I have vista *ultimate on my laptop and xp on my desk, both of them have almost the same config.

but i think ma desk would work fast , but since my lappy is just more speedy , so now i think both of them have the same speed. because it is for vista that my laptop gets a bit slow

I suggest Win XP for all the computer power users. (ofcourse mac is a different thing)

Win Vista is for all the noobs :P

#459421

Win Vista is for all the noobs :P

idiot.

#459426

I have XP and Vista in a dual boot form on one hard drive. Different partition for each OS though.

I have Core 2 Duo e6400, 1GB single channel RAM, nVidia 7600GT... Vista does boot up slow for me, but I use XP all the time, especially for gaming. I only use Vista to play around with or if I gotta try new software to see if it'll work. Don't get Vista unless you have about 2GB of RAM or more, and have a good processor. That's just my advice.

In conclusion, Vista is a little slower than XP for me, but I'm getting more RAM soon, so we'll find out then...

#459431

coldwerturkey..... I actually second that motion !!

But then, I'm running Vista on Core2 Duo 2 Ghz (mobile), with 1 GB of ram and GeForce Go 7400.. and although the UI is snappy with all effects and aero on, with multiple apps it does lags a bit more than XP (when I had XP on the same lappy). But I'll stick with my previous post. If you know how to get speed outta your system, you'll find Vista faster than XP.

#459434

I dunno if Bootcamp and PC are the same but...I just switched from XP to vista on my macbook and vista's faster...

#459441

The one thing that stands out with people who have complaints about Vista is they all use nVidia video cards.

nVidia has crappy support for Vista and Microsoft only provided basic drivers for the cards.

You can blame that on nVidia, not Microsoft.

ATI and even Intel have been on the ball since early Alpha versions and have produced quality drivers for their chip sets.

I have an SB Live card in one of my systems and I haven't had any issues with it under Vista Ultimate.

I'm using the default Microsoft drivers for it... I just need audio, not any additional features, so I have no complaints.

#459443

thanks for all your opinions, some comprehensive ones too!

im sold on vista.

I dont think picassa and thunderbird really match up though to some of the new vista apps.

But then again windows media center XP SP2 (3 the latest?) is really really good... and...in ways I like it more than vista- theres something very solid and simple about it compared to vista which is a little more airy and complex.

I know vista has its annoyances, the control panel.... is frustrating to navigate (even with the search) and they seperated all the tabs...stupid. (dont defend M$, thats silly)

I'm already running Vista on a decent computer (yeah my MBP) and I love it. It seems fast if not faster than xp, and very stable. (but as i said good hardware).

But my question ultimately, is how well it will run on my parents older hardware.

I think the decider has come down to Peskat's comment about the creative sound blaster live 5.1 driver.

if my audio doesnt work, its not worth upgrading.

#459468