External HDD

I have purchaced an IDE/SATA To USB Adapter and I am planing of connecting an internal HDD or Blu-Ray burner to it to make it external but i don't know what type to get (SATA or IDE). So what type should I get?

#437301

Didn't I read somewhere you had an older Mac with no USB 2.0 ?

#437321

No. I have a MacBook.

#437329

aha all makes sense.

I would go for SATA myself, depends how big you want the external HDD to be.

I don't think unless I had a specific reason to have Blu-Ray that I would bother just yet. Drives are topping out at £500GBP $750-$1200US and $20US a disc.

#437332

But any way will IDE work?

#437380

Don't see why not, you have an IDE/SATA adapter.

Just curious.. what are you going to do with the HDD ?

Is it going to be in a case or just sat on the side ?

#437451

An IDE/SATA To USB Adapter is actually a cable; not an adapter or case.

#437453

I know, should be a 40pin IDE cable and power lead to usb.

My point is have you got an external case of some description to put the HDD in?

I wouldn't advise just leaving an internal HDD out in the open or porting it about with you un-protected.

#437459

I don't have a case. :(

#437540

Western Digital MyBook 250 Gb should be good choice or Western Digital 2.5" Passport 80 GB

I have MyBook and to be pleased performance.

#437551

I don't have a case. :(

This is why I originally questioned why you opted for the the IDE/SATA to USB cable.

It would have been easier to buy a USB HDD enclosure from Ebay and then get yourself a cheap HDD, then simply connect through USB or better yet you could get a Firewire Enabled HDD Case.

#437558

I wanted the IDE/SATA to USB cable because i am going to use it for a Blu-Ray burner too.

#437560

You can also get enclosures for External Media writers that will also take HDDs aswell.

As I have said, I wouldn't recommend running any internal devices that are not encased or stabilised.

By the way I have to know just for my own curiosity why you want a Blu-Ray Writer ;)

#437563