Vista Voice Recognition demonstration failure
that is definitely double the killer
"... and you were wondering why Vista keeps getting delayed." ![]()
I'm wondering why you would want Vista at all...
i think MS may want to "delete that" ![]()
thats great!
gosh, for some reason i am compelled to think it's fake or something. that just seem too off!
OS X has voice recognition but it works so it isnt ms taking our ideas again.
i think we have that
or some app or some **** that does it
eithe rway vista sucks
lol at the video. ellada, what a fanboy. ![]()
MS should just buy Dragon Naturally speaking and embedd it
Dear mom.... AHAHAHAHAH
Friends who have used Vista told me that the speech recognition is actually quite good.
MS attributed the failure to echoes in the auditorium. I'm sure the camera microphone does not pick up all the sounds in the room.
It'll probably work when Vista is out. Its just the mandatory windows demo failure.
Further, how well do you expect software to work if you are producing it for literally hundreds of different peripherals? Apple, admittedly, doesn't have this problem. I've used Tiger (and it's voice recognition), and found the recog to be worse than Windows.
It should be easier for Apple with their closed system. Rag on Microsoft all you want, but if Apple had to deal with 12 makers of PCs, hundreds of peripheral makers, etc., you'd quickly see why MS has the trouble it does have. It's a miracle that any of it works.
Before we make fun of Microsoft, let us think the unthinkable. How would Apple handle having a plethora of models, drivers, hardware and software to deal with, all while being forced to used 3rd party stuff? I'd bet the quality of the product would drop.
So while this video may be humorous, I don't see this is as a "jump to a Mac" situation.
@kjohnson: I honestly believe you have no idea what you are talking about.
I don't know what made you bring up the whole 'Apple has a closed system, MS does not' argument. Voice recognition has nothing to do with that at all. It is should work independent of any PC or peripheral maker (seriously..where did this come from?)
The quality of voice recognition software has to do with how well it can pick up spoken words in a human voice; in essence how well the software is written. It has nothing to do with HP, Dell, Lenovo, Acer or any other OEM for that matter. Nor does it have anything to do with the drivers written for the peripheral devices.
If this demo was about poor performance for a particular hardware device (say a graphics accelerator or a sound card), then your argument would hold some weight, but in this case it just flies right back in your face.
Please think through your post and its relevance to the topic next time.
Sid,
Excellent points on all counts. Most of that "rant," if you can call it that (a right bit of a mess, actually), stems from Apple users finding another excuse to bash MS. I still stand behind my views on the matter, however.
That said, If you've used the Voice Recognition packaged with Office XP/2003, you may not have experienced those problems.
I'll admit to giggling at the video. I would prefer if journalists would keep their opinions out of their reporting. Nothing in journalism ethics says it okay to editorialize reports. But that's a argument for another forum.
Aqua-Soft Forums