Proteus vs AdiumX comparison...

Here i'm again =)

Do somebody can compare this two?

pros&cons of both.

Maybe somebody use both?

#382716

I very much prefer AdiumX, because of it's nice GUI and it does everything I need to do and well. I also like the IM styling, etc. Also Proteus currently doesn;t have a universal binary and you have to get the beta release to run it under Rosetta.

Might I ask why you don't just try them both for yourself? No one but yourself can tell you what like.

#382814

AdiumX Hands DOWN !

#382970

tehnick I try Proteus ofcourse. But also i want to here some "other" points of view :)

1 thing i didn't like with AdiumX - its chat history. I miss Hisrory++ plugin for MirandaIM =)

Some days ago I found that my AdiumX history is fullfiled with spam auth requests, status changes and othe kind of spam messages from contacts i didn't know. Clear it is a way long process. And its was a time i read about Proteus ;) And i ask community about it.

There was a chance that all of you geeks says "Proteus? you still didn't use it!? Come on and get it!" =) or something like "Proteus? Who the hell is proteus?"

As a long (i think) member os A-S i belive you guys. And if somebody like Unbe or Pe8er says "its good" atleast i will try it. And than try i t again ;) Just in case I omit something.

Thats why I ask.

Thats why I read.

Thats why we still here, IMHO.

#383011

Is it forbidden to try it on your own? Dude, you are so freaking lazy!

You ask others to try it for you instead of doing it yourself.

#383025

I'm not lazy.

I try it. Its not bad.

Check my question: "Maybe somebody use both?"

Is it prohibited to ask peoples opinions?

OK. I wouldn't do it. np mate.

You can close the thread.

And sorry if i wrong with past/presence/ect sentences :) (or... yes, my english is bad :) )

#383042

I think AdiumX is buggier (or used to be) but is apparently recognized as the better chat client.

-NC

#383084

I never used Proteus and don't like Adium (it has ugly roots) so my opinion on this topic probably sucks :P Anyway my advice is: go for iChat, it's the best! Combine it with Chax extension (get it at macupdate.com) and you won't need anything else.

Seriously - iChat is the only IM app for OS X which provides such flawless integration with other apps (Safari, Address Book, Mail, iTunes) - and it really counts in a long run ;)

#383282

Pe8er you rockkkks =)

i'll give chax a try.

One thing BTW. Is it possible to use ICQ nick in iChat contacts list? I see a numbers only. And I don't have all my buddys in Address Book.

edit

Damn... i have really big issue with iChat :( It doesn't work good with russian chars in chat (incoming one). I think its only some of buddys problem but... it's bad.

Here is a shot

filename3pe.jpg

as you can see, mine text (right side) is in russian. My buddy (left side) is in garbled russian.

#383393

Seriously - iChat is the only IM app for OS X which provides such flawless integration with other apps (Safari, Address Book, Mail, iTunes) - and it really counts in a long run ;)

Adium does integrate fairly well with Apple's apps. It uses Apple's Address Book, Safari, iTunes...shall I go on? If something doesn't integrate, then there are plenty of plugins and scripts that allows Adium to do so - Adium Xtras.

iChat is limited to only running AIM, .Mac and Jabber accounts straight out of the box, but for those of you who have friends, family or colleagues who happen to use other protocols such as MSN, Yahoo, ICQ, Google Talk etc, then iChat is not the client you want. Adium supports all of these protocols and unlike iChat, integrates them nicely into a single contact list. However, Chax is shaping up as a nice extension to iChat which finally allows for tabbed chats.

@NilColor: Try going into iChats Preferences, go to "Messages" and check "reformat incoming messages" and see how that goes, you might also want to try setting the incoming font to the same one that you use for outgoing.

#383418

Adium does integrate fairly well with Apple's apps. It uses Apple's Address Book, Safari, iTunes...shall I go on? If something doesn't integrate, then there are plenty of plugins and scripts that allows Adium to do so - Adium Xtras.

This is exactly my point - how integration is good if I have to download additional stuff to make it efficient? Apple philosophy isn't about making things work by endless tweaking and adjusting. It's about things working out of the box.

Think of buddy icons for example. Go to Address Book and change any buddy icon - you will see it change in Mail and iChat instantly. This is what I mean by integration - two way cooperation.

iChat is limited to only running AIM, .Mac and Jabber accounts straight out of the box, but for those of you who have friends, family or colleagues who happen to use other protocols such as MSN, Yahoo, ICQ, Google Talk etc, then iChat is not the client you want.

I have to disagree. Jabber is a gateway to any possible protocol out there. Maybe it's less comfortable than in Adium but I gladly sacrificed 15 minutes to find a good Jabber server and set up account for it. Now I'm settled and what counts is that everything works flawlessly.

Adium supports all of these protocols and unlike iChat, integrates them nicely into a single contact list.

Well I think it's relative whether it's an advantage. IMO it's a matter of preference and habit. I got used to two contact lists, everything is nicely ordered in a way.

But let's get back to the topic, it was supposed to be Proteus vs Adium war :D

#383533

btw about foreign characters—windows AIM doesn't encode them properly so only those on a Mac are able to type them... which is a reason why many non-US people prefer MSN

ichat can use any service because of jabber...

back to the main topic

Proteus is a beautifully designed application, but just isn't updated enough. And because it's payware, few people use and develop extras/plugins for it.

Adium has many features, but it sacrifices HIG-compliance and a sleek interface for its very extensive customizability.

I just use iChat because of it's tight Apple integration, animations, interface. Thanks to Chax and my own nib mods, iChat is just as functional as Adium and Proteus while maintaining it's splendid user interface 8)

#383600

Proteus is free now Pwn

#383641

Who is Pwan?

@R0GUE

"reformat incoming messages" doesn't help. So... i have to use Adium =) Thanks all of you people for join this war ;) But now is peace time.

PS

@Pe8er

This is exactly my point - how integration is good if I have to download additional stuff to make it efficient? Apple philosophy isn't about making things work by endless tweaking and adjusting. It's about things working out of the box.

vs

I never used Proteus and don't like Adium (it has ugly roots) so my opinion on this topic probably sucks Anyway my advice is: go for iChat, it's the best! Combine it with Chax extension (get it at macupdate.com) and you won't need anything else.

:P

#383683

Oh well :P Chax is the only thing you might want to download. You don't need it, iChat is very good without it. With Adium you have to download additional stuff to get functionality similar to iChat.

#383693

I didn't download nothing for Adium... even themes ) Have I?

And maybe I don't know something useful.

Too bad I have transcript problem with iChat :(

#383694

No offense Pe8er, but AdiumX is far superior to iChat in terms of features and functionality. It's OS X integration is nothing to overlook, but right now it's too far behind competition. No client that doesn't already have tabbed IM windows by default is severly lacking.

I can name probaboly 20 important key features that iChat doesn't have.

You lose too much to only gain so little by switching.

#383856

I gain headache, that's what I gain. You must understand that I'm not going for features but for integration, beauty, simplicity and stability. iChat gives me this right out of the box (or with one tiny adjustement - Chax), Adium doesn't. I seriously am sick of all customizing features in that duck app - there's too many of them for me, I don't need them. From this point of view iChat is superior to Adium. This discussion is pointless because we're starting to talk about our personal needs and tastes - and these cannot be discussed, they all are equal :)

#383868

I tried adiumX and Proteus. and I ended up sticking to Proteus.

Main because of the finderbar thing(im still new to macs forgot what its called)

It simialr to ichat that part of it is kinda buggy sometimes but it still works none the less.

I personally don't like having icons over loading my dock.

although if adiumX did have that option then i will switch to it.

#383883

Adium has many features, but it sacrifices HIG-compliance and a sleek interface for its very extensive customizability.

Have you actually read the HIG?

#447112