Samui 2.0 for WB

LINK REMOVED.

If you're going to "port" something follow this short list:

1. Make sure you get permission from the original author

2. Make sure you do all the work instead of butchering other people's theme

3. Lookup word "moral" in the dictionary

____________________________________________

/Post edited

Unbeliever

#372560

Sweeet. Wonderful job Fire.elf!

#372562

wow- you're on a roll fire.elf- k dowloading right now- though you posted it on the wrong thread

#372565

GREAT JOB! I was patiently (not really) waiting for this to come out :D

/.teh

#372566

Take your time for details.

#372573

I gotta ask it but why aren't skinners as of late taking advantage of the features windowblinds 5.x enables? Alphablended corners and built in shadows to name a few.

Just an innocent question, I really do appreciate the release but I just wanted to pose the observation that to date, as far as I know, only Judge has given us that refined aqua feel that so many here have sought after and have not being able to achieve in its entirety, now that there's the means, there hasn't really been a taker.

I know that many have argued.. why have built in shadows when you can have winfx or yzshadow do the trick but simply take a window and shake it around your desktop and you just might get a sense of what makes built in shadows rock so damn much. Not a tear, or artifact in sight! I do not have a mac but with windowblinds 5.x and built in shadows, I might just be able to imagine.

Anyways... sorry to digress. Thank you for the release, it's good to see a new star in the skinning sphere :)

#372574

Nice theme. But can anyone tell me the difference between samui 1 and 2 ?

#372575

That looks an aweful lot like duyvan82's samui, only with some new elements. Mainly just scrollbars... its using his start pannel too ;)

did duy allow you to use his wb as a base?

by the way this is in the wrong forum

#372578

Ok, let's get real. This is duyvan's style with like 1 or 2 modifications. Who's really going to port this? Or do I have to do this myself?

#372579

i might be dense but i'm running this skin next to a box with duy's skin and outside of a couple things i don't see much difference. as far as permissions go wouldn't the original themer (bzeitler) be the one to grant permission - fire.elf does credit bz.

#372619

Looking back on Psychopulses Samui 2.0 mac theme, samui 1.0 and samui 2.0 really don't look a whole lot different :slant:

#372622

he must have my permission because apparently (if not obviously) he is using my WB to make this one. However I have not been contacted by anybody...

#372623

i just wondered who has to be asked the mac themer or the skinner who first ported it. i'm not defending him or accusing him, it just seems like one of those grey areas to me - it gets less grey if he used elements from your wb version. since he needs your permission duyvan then i'll will delete it from my box until he gets it.

#372625

I admit that this is really confusing. Normally to release a port, you would need the mac themer's permission, that would be enough. However, if you are to use an existing port as a base to make yours, you would also need permission from the person who had previously made that port, in this case me. I think I've made it clear hehe :)

#372626

:( please no more

Thank you for the theme

... wait, this is not for WB5 and has not awesome features (Astyanax & Duyvan82 had spoiled me with WB).

Will Duyvan82 port the official one someday?

#372631

it makes since. my question then would be how to tell if some one uses your elements if both match the original theme?

to explain my angle, as an owner of a tattoo shop my artists do not need permission from an artist/corporation to tattoo that piece of art on a person, say a picture of mickey mouse from a magazine - its third party art not for resale (no one sells the skin - at least no living people do) so its not considered infringement. it was the first thing that came to my mind when i read this thread.

#372632

Looking back on Psychopulses Samui 2.0 mac theme, samui 1.0 and samui 2.0 really don't look a whole lot different :slant:

>_< Psychopulses Samui 2.0 mac theme?? I hope you mean his "screenshot". Anyhow No permission was granted for this theme. (to my knowledge) Someone did contact me via instant message but I told that person I wanted to see any work first.

As for the differenences, their are huge changes between Samui 1.0 and Samui 2.0. You cant tell the difference because of the low quality of this work. This is why people dont like to have themes ported when they look this bad.

I spent alot of time updating Samui 1.0 by refining nearly every single element in the theme to be crisper, cleaner and sharper. I also changed the colors.

Once again... no permission was granted to my knowledge. I certainly would not have authorized this to be released in this state.

comp1.pngcomp2.png

theme4.png

All this being said.. I am not gonna ask that you remove the link. If people want to download and use your version... then so be it.

#372638

@opi8: That's a good question. In order to do so you will have to exploit an imperfection of the original port, then find the same imperfection in the other port. If both coincidentally have the same imperfection(s), then you can be sure. Also, oftentimes, because the XP shell is not the same as the OSX shell, some elements of a port are up to the descretion of the porter as there is no equivalent in the original OSX theme (example being shellstyles). Finding these elements and matching them can also help in identifying whether or not someone else is using a porter's work.

#372639

ok, it's easy to tell whether he's using my theme. Open both themes (mine and this one) in skinstudio, look at the margin settnigs, the filename, skin's structure etc... you'll see the similarities, also, there are some elements that porter must create by themselve, for example shellstyle and log on/off dialog box, start menu etc.

#372642

i have to admit i haven't bothered opening them in skinstudio. i assumed that you would have "signed" your work in some way that only you could see even if some one deleted the obvious permissions that pop up when you open a style in skin studio.

#372646

msstyle and iam happy :o

#372699

so this is a Rip then :( sad

#372713

Yes, and I'm surprised that a moderator didn't close this thread...

#372746

My apologies for my comments on page 1. I don't want to congratulate anyone for doing a rip. :mad:

#372750

So superb style Samui 2.0 and i am still waiting for a official port to Windows.

I mean official , 100% unique and made well.....

For this :( :( :(

This only demage the whole style fun :/

#372752