Lions, Taggers, and Rules... oh my!

Alright, normally I wouldn't say anything, but it's really starting to piss me off. Moderators complain that they have to constantly clean up after people. That's the point of a moderator isn't it. Don't like it, then you don't have to be one, no one is forcing you. If everyone followed the rules, tagged threads, etc. we wouldn't even need moderators. Janitors can't complain that they have to pick up garbage, it's part of the job title.

Sorry for most of this, I'm venting, but the tag thing really pisses me off. I don't even know what the official tags are.

[lions]

King of the Jungle. Need I say more?

[tags]

At least half of the threads I go into, a moderator says to tag the thread because it is not tagged. Yeah that's great and all, but how in the world is anyone supposed to know what the tags are?

If you read the Forum Guidelines, 2.1.3 mentions tagging your thread. NO WHERE in there is a link to the available tags. It simply says "More details regarding thread tagging are available here." Here where? There's no link. No more info. Nothing. It's kind of hard to tag a thread if you don't know what the heck a tag is.

I would like to see some type of modification to making a post, that presents a drop down box, with a list of all available tags and you must select one. Then the tag is appended to the topic title.

Other than Pe8ers signature, I don't know of a way to get to the information about tags. Which makes me wonder, have the people here who tell others to tag, actually read the rules? If so, they would have noticed that there is no link or info on tagging.

[rules]

As has been mentioned before, we need a button at the top in the navigation bar, that says rules. Even on the main board page, there is no clear link to the rules. You have to go into an actual forum, and then see it at the top. No offense, but personally I hardly ever even see it.

I think it would be nice if on the main board page, with "Important Aqua-Soft Information" and "Comments and Suggestions", there was another entry at the very top that simply said "Forum Guidelines" and took you to the guidelines.

It would also be nice, if after a new member registered, instead of the registration taking them to the board index, it took them to the Forum Guidelines page.

I think that a "Forum Guidelines" link should be added to the Quick Links menu as well.

I personally feel "Forum Guidelines" should be named to Forum Rules. It is more clean and concise. For those of you who can't imagine how the word "Guidelines" is not concise, keep in mind a good portion of this board does not speak English well. When a member or moderator says "read the rules", anyone who does not understand English very well, may not make the connection between rules and "Forum Guidelines".

[double posting/bumping]

Sometimes double posting/bumping is beneficial. The board sends an e-mail to me whenever a new reply is made in a thread I have posted in. If a person posts a question then no one posts for a week, that thread gets forgotten about, I forget about it, etc. If they edit their topic (or create a new one, in which case they'll be told to search because its been posted before), I'll never know unless I take the time to go hunt down threads. But when they post again, I get a new e-mail and am reminded of something I had entirely forgotten about. When a moderator posts "don't double-post" or "don't bump a thread" after someone has posted, all that does is just bump the thread again and defeat the purpose.

#361972

Tags are not a rule on this forum, I've said it many times and I'll continue to say it again, I DO NOT support tags, you can choose to use them or not. If you're going to use tags, you use them in the CUSTOMIZING forums, no where else.

#361978

Good argument flyakite. But, the way I have learned about tags on this forum is in one of my first posts, which can be located here, was closed and tagged by Seph. That was my first experience with tags, soon enough I started copying what other members were doing. For example, if someone posted an icon release, they would type "[Release] Title Here" or if it was a work in progress "[WIP] Title Here". I'm just saying that's how I learned, but copying what others do.

But, yes, a nice little guideline redirect for newly registered member is a good idea.

#361983

Go flyakite go flyakite!!!

I also noticed a few situations where someone makes a topic requesting information and they get linked to an outdated historic topic where everything is old and new information is nowhere present. and then I wonder about the "no bumping" so pretty much the poor guy not only gets flak for making a topic about something that already existed a while ago but they get flak also for posting at that old topic!

________________________________________________________________________________

__________

Edit: Example:

A Moderator:

//Thread Closed.

________________________________________________________________________________

__________

Though some of the links are dead, here's the thread you searched for but couldn't find .

http://www.aqua-soft.org/board/showthread.php?t=10188

An Admin:

If they were to post in that thread, someone would of came along and closed it because tehy bumped it.

I'll re-open this one, just obey the forum rules and keep it on topic.

#361985

was closed and tagged by Seph.

Yay for Seph!

It's obviously too little too late, but if you were interested, here are the tagging guidelines: Tagging Guidelines

I'm fairly certain I had something more to say but I'm quite tired so...good night!

-NC

#361994

That quote was related to one of my first posts and how I learned about tags, I wasn't complaining that it was closed because I know about guiKits now. :P

#362002

No, I was just commenting because...it's Seph, you know...Seph. Yeah :P.

-NC

#362004

Speaking of people who are never around anymore, NC you haven't been online in forever, what the heck man?

#362006

personally, i think everyone should use tags b/c it makes filtering the daily reads much much easier... i appreciate it when someone uses a tag and a well phrased, consise title

#362009

Speaking of people who are never around anymore, NC you haven't been online in forever, what the heck man?

Been busy sacrificing virgin goats to my deity Jobso. He gets more demanding around the winter months though, so I should be online more in the future.

-NC

#362012

I think in the customizing forums there should be a "Tag:" text box before the "Title:" one, and one of those ?s with a link, next to it so ****s can find out what it means. Then it will just make the title the text entered in the tag box, then the text in the title box.

I also support the idea of having a rules button on the thingy that looks like a toolbar. (Maybe it disapeares after 35 unreported, unclosed posts/threads.

~Wuzzie

#362028

Got a better idea, removal of all Tags,

#362030

Ok, here is the deal.

When you're posting a new thread, you can choose one of the tags from the dropdown menu we have next to the topic title box. Now on some forums it is REQUIRED to select one, but on others it is not. I have turned off tags on certain forums as well, so users know when they have to tag or not (aka GD).

So tag when you need to, don't tag if you don't have to, DO NOT and I REPEAT DO NOT make up your own tags. If I see [link] in a topic title from now on, the users post will be deleted.

If there is a tag I left out from the list, let me know and I'll think about adding it.

  • Help
  • Release
  • Request
  • Preview

#362039

Once you pop, you can't stop!

Nice work Tim.

#362040

You forgot [question], though I admit it's rarely used anymore. What's wrong with [link]? It works nicely in the General Web forums. I'll probably IM you more stuff later.

-NC

#362070

I didn't forget question, use Help, surely if you need help you're going to ask a question.

Also LINK and DISCUSS are tags that are useless, if there is a link in the thread doesn't mean you need to change the topic title to it.

#362073

I've been waiting forever for this to be implemented. Excellent work Timan.

#362074

Announcement/ [Ann] ? :P

-NC

#362076

this topic is good

#362078

Announcement/ [Ann] ? :P

-NC

Not sure about announcement, its just too long and would make the forum display look odd.

#362080

http://www.aqua-soft.org/board/showthread.php?t=31926

Thanks! I also like the way old tags have been all reformatted to the new system. Good work man!

#362094

Just so you know Zaft, the idea you "proposed" isn't exactly new--it's been floating around for a while now ;).

@Timan--Am I doomed to failure in your eyes?!?!?! :P

-NC

#362168

good thing this is here.. poor thing it takes a well-respected member to get this done.. this has been requested before many times (I remember at least 3 times) and then there never was any attention for it.. but when flyakite (much respect bro') asks for it, it's arranged in minutes.. but hey.. cheer.. it's here..

#362226

good thing this is here.. poor thing it takes a well-respected member to get this done.. this has been requested before many times (I remember at least 3 times) and then there never was any attention for it.. but when flyakite (much respect bro') asks for it, it's arranged in minutes.. but hey.. cheer.. it's here..

I'm more than certain I didn't cause this, I think Tim finally just got fedup and decided to take the time to do it.

#362229

Thank you Timan! Those new tags are nice!

#362269