This isn't a which is better question. What is it about Firefox that allows it to correctly render some sites that Safari doesn't. I realize the easy answer is that if a website was developed "CORRECTLY" (whatever that means) that it would work in all browsers... but I thought the underpinnings of Safari and Firefox were similar. I can't use my online banking or online university websites with Safari...but they work with Firefox.
[question] Safari vs. Firefox
What is the question you are trying to ask then, if it isn't which is better?
What is the question you are trying to ask then, if it isn't which is better?
Jef is asking, since FireFox and Safari both use the Mozilla engine (Gecko?), why is it that FireFox (on Mac) renders a site more accurately that Safari (also on Mac).
I am not sure I understand completely what aspects of the engine are used in comparison to what things are done in the code of the browser. I think CSS may be external, though I am not positive. Also, could a different version of the engine may be used?
Hmm, someone could help you better, I just raise questions.
Safari uses the KHTML engine. Firefox uses the Gecko engine. Different developers, different codebases, different priorities in getting those things working.
I don't know where you get the idea that their underpinnings are similar. They work in completely different ways.
Is the KHTML engine derived from the Gecko engine? If not, then why is it that when you do a browser detection on a web-site that Safari and FireFox both get returned as Mozilla? This is perplexing me.Safari uses the KHTML engine. Firefox uses the Gecko engine. Different developers, different codebases, different priorities in getting those things working.
Is the KHTML engine derived from the Gecko engine? If not, then why is it that when you do a browser detection on a web-site that Safari and FireFox both get returned as Mozilla? This is perplexing me.
I don't know if that happens on every computer since I don't have a Mac, but browser detection is pretty much meaningless. The website is simply displaying to you the user agent string that the web browser reports. It is possible (and actually quite simple in Firefox and Opera) to change your User Agent to whatever you'd like. Often, it's useful to have Opera report itself as Internet Explorer so that websites (like MSN) that do stupid stuff like display better-formatted content to IE will display that content to Opera pretending to be IE.
Is the KHTML engine derived from the Gecko engine? If not, then why is it that when you do a browser detection on a web-site that Safari and FireFox both get returned as Mozilla? This is perplexing me.
IE used to return Mozilla as well. It's meaningless.
KHTML is the engine developed by the Konquerer development team. It has no basis in Gecko or or any Mozilla product.
OK, I was confuzzeled there. Thanks for the information guys
.
To answer the original question, no browser is perfect. Differences between them include:
* differences in default HTML rendering
* different display of CSS (with their own unique bugs)
* slight differences in application of DOM and javascript
If Safari doesn't work with some site you need to use, but Firefox does... well, you know what you need to do. ![]()
Aqua-Soft Forums