Songbird

Anyone tried this app out:

Songbird

Haven't tried it out but it looks nice.

Edit: It's out! I'm downloading to try it :)

#339715

If by "nice" you mean a total iTunes ripoff :slant:

#339717

haha, rip-off maybe, cheap knock-off for sure cause its works the same as iTunes except its twice as ugly

#339720

Good find. Finally a library enabled player (also) for Linux that does not need KDE/Gnome or other bloat. Never mind the looks - Linux players never got past Winamp2 without media library!

#339726

i like the dark interface , someone should port it to mplugin

anyway i think it's a toall ripoff of itunes (ok it's for linux too :) ) but amarok just rule on linux

#339734

I think this looks promising. It will be built on mozilla code, which could make it more open to thirdparty extensions. (Allthough their own code seems to be propertiary, so we'll just have to wait and see)

Perhaps if they can find the sweetspot between features and bloat...

#339814

they already addressed the songbird vs itunes issue.

#339841

Yeah - it's finally out (currently for windows only). First impressions:

- An 8 MB download

- That expends to a 33 MB install

- Handles about every type of audio file thrown at it without choking

- Eats 91 MB of RAM (worse than iTunes) 86 MB on page file (better than iTunes)

- No crossfade, equalizer, loudness or any sound enhancements (soon to come, they say)

- Not a single settings dialog

- Very poor ID3 tag handling, no album art etc., displays year column always as 0 (zero)

- Unix sorting: mistakes ABBA and Abba to be different groups, sorts a-ha behind Ziggy Marley (lowercase after uppercase) - use stricmp() in your qsort() callback, dumbasses

- Incomplete navigation: Previous button ignores shuffle history

- Plain ugly miniplayer mode

My summary:

Apart the expectable 'user preview' quirks, very promising, very cool, present functionality hints at huge future potential. I have seen much worse proof of concept releases.

Now I'm just dying to see the Linux version.

#357962

Ooh. I heard about this a bit back, been waiting to try it out. Thanks for the info, just downloaded it!

As for the things herd said, it probably won't become my first media player. Of course, that's just for now. I can definately see using it in the future, in a later full release. Been looking to throw away iTunes, but nothing quite felt the same. BTW, I'm only getting 50K RAM usage while playing a file. That's about around/less than my iTunes.

The only thing that kind of disappoints me is that it crashes a lot for me, just like Firefox (which it has the same engine as). : With a web browser it's bearable, but maybe not with a music player.

#358077

Thanks for sharing... maybe I'll try it out.... I too, agree that itunes takes up quite a bit of resources.

#358209

I've never seen a bigger rip off of iTunes

#358698

I think it's awsome.

Mac finally is being competed by a little company and is getting bashed for it.

I do think it was ripped of of itunes, but heck, it looks alot better to me!

Ok ok.... ther may be a few coding flaws or whatever but, dude, they have like six guys work 24/7 on it trying to make it bettter.

so im guess it could still even be called a beta, with all the thing you say is wrong with it.

#359425

As an XP user I'm not sure why I would run a full 1.0 release of this if or when it comes rather than iTunes itself unless it halfed the resource consumption.

I wonder if its skinnable in the way that QCD is - possibly it could look like anything.

Mike - who needs to find time to play around with ml_ipod (Winamp iPod Manager).

#359464

thanks bro

#361526

If you don't mind the occasional high overhead, this blows any other media player around. You can browse for new media. If there's media on a webpage, it'll take the songs etc and make a playlist at the bottom as if they were in your library. You can add the songs to your library or download quite a few them. It has some impressive searches. It doesn't really do the album art crap, but the fact that it plays everything includng songs from the iTunes store. I don't think there's a better way to integrate your entire media library, online and ofline, than this app.

As far as the iTunes clone skins: "Good artists copy, great artists steal." -Picasso

#468818

Let the dead thread rest.

//Topic closed.

#468900