How to kill an iPod? let Creative tell you how......

Brief History:

By now, most of us know what an iPod is.. and it's creator company, apple does not need introduction. Apple iPod, is currently positioned as number one mp3 player and hold a large share in mp3 player market. It's been loved by masses for it's functionality, down-to-earth simple usabilty, audio quality and it's one of a kind looks.

Also we know a company called Creative. It's probably the last and best name in audio hardware for PC market. For a record they too have their own line of Mp3 players, with some really good models (called Zen and Zen extra). Now, like many rival companies Creative too tried to take over iPod's domination of mp3 player market. Some time back, they very aggresively declared war on iPod with their new models (calling them "iPod killers"), just to finish off somehere among others below the line. iPod, however remained unbeaten.

Current Events:

1) Creative wins patent for portable media player interface

In what can only be seen as a potential problem for Apple, Creative Technology said today that it has been awarded U.S. Patent 6,928,433 — which it is referring to as the “Zen Patent” — for portable media player navigation. “The Zen Patent was awarded to Creative for its invention of the user interface for portable media players, including many of the Creative Zen and NOMAD Jukebox MP3 players, and found in some competing players, such as the Apple iPod and iPod mini,” the company said in its announcement of the patent win.

“Creative’s invention for the user interface for portable media players enables selection of at least one track in a portable media player as a user sequentially navigates through a hierarchy using three or more successive screens on the display of the player,” the company explains. “One example would be the sequence of screens that could display artists, then albums, and then tracks. When the user selects an artist, the player displays a list of albums for that artist. Selection of one of the listed albums then displays a list of tracks on the album.”

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Now not only Creative have patents in hand for software interface used on iPods, they decide to use it as weapon against iPod, obvisouly their players couldn't do the job.

2) Creative considers legal action over patent violation

Apple may soon come under legal pressure from Creative Technology now that the Singapore-based company has been awarded a patent that it says the iPod infringes upon. Creative has already openly accused Apple of violating the patent, which covers the way users navigate music selections on a portable device, and the company told The New York Times that it is considering every option available to defend the patent, including possible legal action.

Craig McHugh, president of Creative’s United States operations, said yesterday that Apple was the only company identified so far that was in violation of the patent, though Creative was investigating others. “We are looking at all our alternatives right now,” McHugh said. “We have always been very vigorous in our defense of our patent portfolio.”

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Now this really sounds and feels like the ‘sore loser’ is doing his worse here; Creative openly declared war on Apple’s iPod with its “iPod Killers”, that plan went down the drain and caused its stock to fall a while back.

Now they found one avenue to “rip” Apple off and they are publishing the patent news all over the world. Now why isn’t there more news and louder publicity about a stock of Zens carrying a virus worm?? Now that will affect a consumer more directly than anything else.

And talking about worm in Creative Players here's some more details on the news:

3) Creative Ships Wormy Zen Neeons

Creative has shipped approximately 3,700 Zen Neeons that are infected with a worm in their file system.

According to the company's site, the problem has affected the 5GB Creative Zen Neeon with serial numbers between 1230528000001 and 1230533001680. The worm, W32.Wullik.B@mm, which runs on the Windows operating system, will only infect a PC on which it is executed.

Graham Cluley, senior technology consultant, Sophos, said that, when you connect an MP3 player to your computer, the PC normally treats it as just another disk drive. That means you can scan it with the antivirus software on your computer or have the 'always-on' protection that's running on your PC, intercept the virus as you try and copy it to your hard drive.

So, as long as you have kept your regular antivirus software up-to-date then you should have nothing much to worry about, he added.

The problem, however, is only restricted to Asia-Pacific as the Neeon is not available elsewhere.

Mikko Hypponen, chief research officer at antivirus firm F-Secure, said that an infected PC used during the Neeon testing phase may be responsible. Currently there are no leads as to how the worm got onto the player.

.

#312883

Another way to kill the ipod is use a nasty font while posting... really ticks the ipod users off :P

#312913

OOps.. sorry Ti.. I wrote the whole thing in my Word.. and then pasted, I really forgot that it was using different font... my bad, mate. Sorry Again !!

#312916

Sometimes patents are just ridiculous. The iPod interface is nothing more than the implementation of a popup menu with nested submenus... or the equivalent of a hard disk tree structure with nested folders.

The structure of genres/artists/albums/tracks existed in iTunes (and in other media players as well) for years, and it requires common sense to come up with something like that. How can someone hold a patent for it, or for an interface that uses this logic?

Maybe they should also have a patent for a "Play" button (which starts playing music upon being depressed) :-P

#313131

Rediculous...I hope iPod wins back....

I bought a creative Zen Touch and now looking at a 60Gb colour iPod photo...at the moment there is just no substitute for the real thing...

for those interested, the zen's software made it not worth using...difficult and couldn't use it with a mac...dont mean to start a iPod vs iPod killer debate....but its true

there will only ever be one iPod.

#313156

Indeed, iPods are the sony walkmans of our time, sure there were other brands, but everyone wanted a sony walkman. Creative/Sony/et al can try to make them smaller, look cooler, cheaper, but people will still want an iPod because its become a status symbol now, the intuitive software and good design are just a plus now.

I've had 3 ipods in the past, and none have disapointed me, my friend begged me to get a zen instead, I didn't even consider it for a milisecond.

*me waits for Benyamin/NC to correct my spelling mistakes*

#313157

I've had 3 ipods in the past, and none have disapointed me, my friend begged me to get a zen instead, I didn't even consider it for a milisecond.

*me waits for Benyamin/NC to correct my spelling mistakes*

why not lou?! its "millisecond" by the way...

and yes, this is ridiculous.

// Lou

#313159

I stand corrected.

#313160

I stand corrected.

Well, you may stand corrected, but I just sit.

// Lou

#313161

Indeed, iPods are the sony walkmans of our time, sure there were other brands, but everyone wanted a sony walkman. Creative/Sony/et al can try to make them smaller, look cooler, cheaper, but people will still want an iPod because its become a status symbol now, the intuitive software and good design are just a plus now.

I've had 3 ipods in the past, and none have disapointed me, my friend begged me to get a zen instead, I didn't even consider it for a milisecond.

Not bad...only two spelling mistakes (one is only if you're really pedantic), and a few grammar and capitalization points. Personally, I might have phrased it a bit differently, but that's just me.

:P

-NC

#313163

Guys Guys... please stay on topic... :)

#313231