(Help) Trying to Compile App Reviews

Hi everyone. I'd like to start off by saying that this is only my first week in the Customization realm, and that not only do I appreciate you guys contributing to this vast archive of knowledge, but I really feel for you guys when some ****ie like myself posts a thread asking for something that he could have just searched for. It's in that spirit that I write this.

As I try to get familiar with the myriad customization oppurtunities and their corresponding solutions, I'm also trying to compile a "****ie Starter Guide" if you will, a catch-all information stop for all us ****ies so we don't have to bother the rest of you so much.

But as I'm still inexperienced myself, I have no help to offer other ****ies. As it is, I'm just searching the forums for the stuff I need and bookmarking it so I can gather a near complete, and clearly structured guide to everyone trying to break into the customization game.

What I'm struck by most is that for any given single element of Windows that can be customized, there are a great number of applications that will customize that one element. That is, there is a lot of redundancy in the world of customizing Windows. And with 100 solutions per every one problem, it leaves me wondering which solution I should choose for myself. I could ask the forum, but not only would I get chastised for not doing my own searching, even the people dedicated to helping me could only tell me what works best for them. And that's understandable.

What I'm interested in finding are reviews and comparisons, and the more concise and thorough, the better. Of course, this whole forum is almost like a network of reviews open to any and all that wish to search it. And certainly I have done so, and found some excellent stuff. What I'm wondering though is if anyone knows where I can get ahold of some more formal reviews. Like instead of someone posting a question about program X and then everyone chimes in with their two cents on program X, is there any posts that are basically: "Review of Flyakite," "Comparison of all Finder Bars," Review of ObjectDock," etc.?

I'm not asking for these reviews so much as I'm asking for the help of anyone that knows right off hand where to point my attention so that I can be the one to post a thread with the subject, "Review: ObjectBar" and the like.

It's like the ****ies act like these helpless guys in Intensive Care Units, and they need an even more special and dedicated support network to nurse them to Customozition health. Well, I'm all for that network, but I think ****ies should do all the work to create it, given the resources are pretty much all right here.

I'm not asking anybody to dig for me, but if any of you have some bookmarks that sound like what I'm looking for, I'd appreciate the link. Or even if somebody met this dude, I think his name was Randy, and he wears baseball hats, sometimes, and he knew a lot about.. stuff... then you can tell me to look out for theis one dude Randy in a ball cap...

#292226

Sounds like a good idea to me. You might want to look at the stickies around the forum - There are some very helpful ones along the lines of your review ;)

Good luck

#292228

wow, fast response. thanks. this may be, cross that, is a dumb question but, are the stickies always at the top of the list of threads?

#292230

Yep, and that's why they are stickies :)

#292233

Hehe, I add this idea about a year ago...good luck getting it started (I don't mean that in the negative sarcastic way that it sounds).

Unbe wrote an in-depth Konfabulator review for AquaXP.

There have been some reviews on the frontpage...there's a good one that I wrote for Flyakite OS X 2.

If you need more help, PM me.

-NC

#292316

No, I didn't take it in the negative sarcastic way it sounds because I imagine the same things that are going through my head right now were going through yours a year ago. But yeah, I'm not saying I'll be finished tomorrow or anything...maybe a year form now :)

#292691

I might added a review section in my site soon. For those who interested to be a writer please contact me. For the time being, careyt, my fellow admin agree to make a review for a few applications. Me myself will make some reviews. And if you would like to read a reviews on themes, just wait for stylesuites to be relaunch at the end of this month

#292867