CherryOS goes "Open Source"

Hah, I figured you guys would get a kick out of this; check out the CherryOS main page.

Shortly after "closing", they've made it into the "Cherry Open Source Project".

I love how they've got a picture of the GNU gnu there. :D

#271783

Thats just comical.

#271795

if there was irony in the world, CherryOS OSS is it :slant:

#271798

ridiculous

#271801

I wonder if Microsoft would ever say "due to overwhelming demand" we've decided to make Windows XP open-source...

#271813

I wonder if Microsoft would ever say "due to overwhelming demand" we've decided to make Windows XP open-source...

Opening the source is all well and good, but unless MS would allow patch submissions from hackers and regular joes (which I doubt they'd do), it would probably be safer to keep it closed. With the amount of security flaws that are found through testing alone, can you imagine what some dedicated villain would be able to find with the code bare before them?

#271816

That's just too funny.

I would hate to see the M$ source code for XP... that would be a nightmare to go through.

#271824

that would be a nightmare to go through.

Why? (10 char minimum sucks)

#271831

i guess that cherryos guys know that sooner or later they are going to be sued, and kicked out. so they chose to give up and be embarressed rather than trying to cover up what they stole. serves them right. and, the performance is going to be just as low as the first ever pear pc official build. don't bother with these morons.

#271832

I feel sorry for the people who have spent money on this ****!

#271837

nya~ wtf are they trying to do?

and what if, and only if, they have original code?

#271841

and what if, and only if, they have original code?

Highly unlikely, but if that happens, then... people go on with their day. Many people will be surprised, but I doubt anything massive will happen.

Besides, if they're using PearPC code, then they've already violated the GPL.

From the GPL:

4. You may not copy, modify, sublicense, or distribute the Program except as expressly provided under this License. Any attempt otherwise to copy, modify, sublicense or distribute the Program is void, and will automatically terminate your rights under this License. However, parties who have received copies, or rights, from you under this License will not have their licenses terminated so long as such parties remain in full compliance.

So, since they've violated the GPL for PearPC, and they'd still technically be in violation, because they relinquished their rights to the licensed product the moment they closed its source. At least, that's the way I read it.

#271850

Opening the source is all well and good, but unless MS would allow patch submissions from hackers and regular joes (which I doubt they'd do), it would probably be safer to keep it closed. With the amount of security flaws that are found through testing alone, can you imagine what some dedicated villain would be able to find with the code bare before them?

Linux is open source :o

#271862

You realise they are just trying to slip away quietly and hope everyone forgets about CherryOS in a few months.....The code will never be released.

#271864

Linux is open source :o

And they screen and accept patches from ANYONE who wants to submit 'em. I was saying MS would have to do that to keep up.

#271869

Not only that, but G4 TV is making a segment on CherryOS and how great it is.

Apparently not only do their shows now suck, but their research does too.

#271873

Either way, they broke the terms, they broke the law, they have no rights to use PearPC code, and they are still going to get their asses sued.

Pooky: Attack of the Show has Kevin in it right?

He was the first one to announce PearPC to the world via Television.

But yeah, G4 really just made money by selling TechTV's local channel to BET and then cutting it down to about 2 tech shows and the rest being all game shows.

That gets me ENRAGED!

#271901

i remembered when thescreensavers reviewed pearpc, and now cherryos became opensource because they are desperate for outside help. well whoptydo don't help them!

#271999

what exactly do u mean by 'open-source'?

#272005

what exactly do u mean by 'open-source'?

they'll put a link to the PearPC website in their readme. :P

#272071

what exactly do u mean by 'open-source'?
I wouldn't be surprised if they tried to pull some stunt like claiming the "OS" in "CherryOS" always stood for Open Source. :P

#272131