Many a **** have found themselves saying, "What theming program should I use?" That is one question with many answers, WindowBlinds, StyleXP, the UXTheme patch, and now Styler. Here's my lowdown.
Program Information
Stardock WindowBlindsWindowBlinds is the only application that doesn't use .msstyles. It is very powerful, allowing the user to manipulate Window's appearance in many ways. You can add buttons, change window colors and more. Someone hoping to emulate OS X will want to use WindowBlinds, as it is the only skinning app that allows the titlebar buttons to be moved to the left. WindowBlinds as well gives the ability to assign different skins to certain applications, so Explorer can be one skin, Firefox a second, and another skin for everything else. Also, since WindowBlinds doesn't use the UXTheme.dll, it takes less system resources then even Microsoft's Luna. For an indepth look, go here. WindowBlinds can be downloaded for free (but the scrollbar will always be the Windows Classic one) or purchased from Stardock for $20 or $50 as part of the Object Desktop application suite.
Advantages: Increases functionality/manipulatibility of windows, less system resources used
Disadvantages: It costs $20, many MSStyles don't look so good when initially converted
StyleXP
StyleXP by TGT Soft is a manager that lets a user control visual styles, bootscreens, logons, icons and wallpapers. It should be noted that everything StyleXP does can be done by the user for free, but StyleXP costs $20, coming only with a few ugly skins. The best part of StyleXP is that you can now uses icon packages, a rip-off of Stardock's IconPackager, which lets you massively change your icons, a real time saver. This program should only be the choice of those who are not tech-savvy, and those who change icons very frequently. StyleXP can be purcahsed for $20 from TGT Soft.
Advantages: Lets the not-so tech-savvy use skins; brings visual styles, wallpapers, logons, bootscreens, and icons into one application
Disadvantages: It costs $20, doesn't do much you can't do for free
UXTheme Patch
Simply patching Windows XP's UXTheme.dll opens up the entire world of MSStyles. An easy, free patch installer is available at Neowin. Note that it cannot in any way increase Window's vulnerability to viri or spyware.
Advantages: This is entirely free.
Disadvantages: Some people do not want to edit anything in the Windows directory. The user will have to replace the dll with every XP build update.
__________________
Styler
I seperated Styler because it uses the patched UXTheme.dll and can also be used with WindowBlinds. The newcomer to the skinning crowd, Styler shows a lot of promise. It gives the user the ability to manage MSStyles, really cool custom toolbars, wallpapers, and several other affects. The main use of Styler is its custom toolbars, which perfectly simulate the OS X Finder toolbar, without the loss of functionality. People wanting to emulate OS X should get this, but everyone else should think about it, because the free Y'zToolbar can skin toolbars, and Y'zShadow (also free) can do the shadow affects. Styler can be purchased for ¥1500 from Style Fantasist.
Advantages: Really cool functional toolbars, convenient manage
Disadvantages: Aside from a few really awesome features its just like StyleXP, costs ¥1500 (like $17)
Skins
MSStyles
There are way more MSSytles than WindowBlinds skins. There are many great themes available for free download everywhere. If you're not going to be just OS X emulating, you will find MSStyles much more rewarding, seeing as there is a huge variety of themes. Just be prepared to face many Luna variants and Longhorn-styled themes. Many themes include cool shellstyles and extras.
WindowBlinds Skins
Most good WindowBlinds skins are ports, either from MSStyle or Mac OS X. They usually come with custom toolbars and animations. Some of them even come with all the substyles you'd ever need.
Which One is Right for Me?
So what's right for you? That's really up to you, but here's my personal opinion if you're...
Wealthy: Buy 'em all, then give me some money.
A Hardcore OS X Emulator: Get WindowBlinds and Styler, and consider also buying ObjectDesktop for ObjectBar and IconPackager.
Really Low on Resources: Buy WindowBlinds.
Just Skinning to Make XP Less Ugly: Patch the UXTheme.dll, that's all you really need.
Confused: Get StyleXP or a friend who can help.
Other Helpful Guides
Anyway, this all is just my $0.50. I'll expand on this later if this thread isn't deemed useless.
Aqua-Soft Forums