[Help] Upgrade laptop or get new desktop?

I'm currently using a Sony VGN-A190 laptop with 512MB, 60GB and XP Home SP2. It's having some serious performance issues. Mainly, HD access is constant (especially when using OD+), and the wait time to perform simple tasks, such as opening a folder in Explorer or copying files to a new folder, can take up to 10 seconds. Additionally, opening my most used apps, such as Photoshop and MS VC++ can take even longer (for PS, nearly 40 seconds!!).

I've gone through the whole "speed this computer up" maze, and have used any number of apps to help out - such as intensely defragging, cutting running processes to a minimum, etc.

My options are to either upgrade the HD and mem on the laptop or get a whole new desktop box. If I upgrade, I'm thinking of 1GB RAM and a 7200 RPM HD (as opposed to the 5400 RPM that's in the laptop now). But, there are issues here, such as the fact that the unit is still under warranty and I'd probably have to go through Sony to get these upgrades - which would mean paying through the nose for something I could do myself for the cost of the components.

If I just get a new desktop, then I'm thinking of either a Hush ATX or a Cubit P4 for space saving on my desk. I'd certainly gain in the area of raw speed, but then I'd have to also get a new monitor. This is tough for me to imagine, since the LCD on the laptop is probably the best one I've ever seen (Sony got that one right). I don't have the room for a CRT, so I'd be looking for an LCD. The only models I've found that come close to the VGN-A's are from Apple and Sony - both very expensive. Tight resolution and extreme sharpness are vital to me, but even if I run a desktop LCD at the same or better res as the laptop (1920x1200), the physical size of a desk model pretty much negates the effect (running 1920x1200 on a 17" LCD is quite sexier than the same res on a 23" desk model).

Any advice you can offer in this area would be greatly appreciated!

#225873

hm. i don't think it's the laptop that's the problem.

if possible send your laptop to the manufacturer for a cpu and ram and hd upgrade.

i don't think getting a new desktop is worth it because your laptop still has the problem, and you are dishing out much more money than you should.

i sugesst backing up essensial files and resetting the whole system. keep it clean. my computer was slugish as crawling babies against the ferrari. then i backed up my homewrok and music files and other essensial stuff (like backing up the whole stardock folder so i can keep all my docks and settings and icons intact) then resett the whole computer. after resetting the system, copy from the backup harddisk and return your themes and configureations to the old style.

remember to keep you computer clean. only instal the most essensial stuff like windowblinds, adobe reader, microsoft office, objectdock, and the things you can't live without. other speedup programs do increase performance, but the program itself can contribute to the sluggishness. my computer used to hickup when using the objectdock, but after resetting it and keeping it clean it worked a lot faster.

it would be good to provide more information, like

graphics card

cpu

ram, and what kind of ram 400? or 333?

what you do with your computer

i don't find a real need for a second computer, but your needs may be diffrent.

#226069

Scan your system for sypware. The symptoms what your computer is showing suggests that you might have a major infestation.

#226070

Backup, reinstall Windows and see if it helps

#226103

OK, these are great suggestions. Thanks steelfist for the detailed reply. When I said that I might want to get a desktop system, it would be to replace the laptop, not add to it - I'm not wealthy, after all.

My laptop specs are:

Proc - 1.70 gigahertz Intel Pentium M

64 kilobyte primary memory cache

2048 kilobyte secondary memory cache

Vid - ATI MOBILITY RADEON 9700

RAM - 512, Sorry, don't know the speed

Mobo - Bus Clock: 100 megahertz

BIOS: American Megatrends Inc. R0030F1 03/23/2004

I use my laptop for the following:

- C++ development

- Heavy Photoshop (photo manipulation, editing, printing)

- Heavy word processing (Office)

- 3dsmax

- Authoring/duping/playing DVDs & CDs

- Playing MP3's

- Surfing

- Chat

- Occassional FTP

- Warcraft III, Half-Life

- VS, icon & applet development

- Web design

Ironically, the games perform the best, and OD+ and Explorer perform the WORST. Perhaps, as you suggested, harsha_c, I'm infected and need a thorough sweep. I'm a hesitant to completely wipe the system at this point, but perhaps that's what it needs. I'm sure I could definitely slim her down and remove a LOT of unused apps.

#226140

i've also found my laptop be very annoying slow at times. but i'm pretty sure i could never run 3dsmax on it!

anyone know of any 7200rpm laptop hdd's aside from this one? another 20gb wouldn't hurt :D

#238317