Objectdock Plus Best Functional Dock Available

I think the Stardock Objectdock Plus is the best functional dock available because it allows a great number of folders and applications to be launched and accessed quicker in an organized fashion than the traditional Mac Dock and the Windows emulators like Yz dock and Stardock original Objectdock. The tab functions of Objectdock allows better navigation than the other docks. Some purist will not accept anything other than a complete Mac look-alike even when it is an inferior product but that is left for that like to argue at infinitum based on substance rather than facts. There's nothing here that does not allow you to run more than one dock from different makers.

Objectdock Plus has some areas that could be improved, although minor in substance could give a better user experience. This is meant as a suggestion to improve the dock experience rather than bugs that must be addressed or changed. Here is a COMPOSITE reference image that illustrates the following suggestions. :

ObjectdockPlus.jpg

1 The tabs are always visible. I think a better solution from an esthetic point of view, would be a complete "hide of the docks including tabs" that come down with mouse over.

2 The next problem comes in re-sizing the dock itself at the edges where the standard double arrow <--> indicates the ability to re-size. The resize is slow to respond and choppy not giving you good control. (I'm using an nVidia card 2Ghz P4)

3 The third problem is that placing a new shortcut in the dock or drag n drop a shortcut can be tricky when the dock has more than 1 part meaning that the next set of icons continue on the next dock pane after one presses the right arrow (>).

For example if I were to create a new shortcut in the dock by dragging the yellow box (SystemWorks app) The House icon will automatically shift to the second pane dock. Rearranging icons between the second pane to the first pane I found it to be impossible. One can push icons from the first pane to the second pane but not the otherway . This forces people to think and plan very carefully the lay-out of the icons between panes. As a second example of the same problem one could place the Yellow box icon on the first pane but one could not move the folder with the red cross from the second pane to the first pane.

4 The image that is used to navigate between panes of a given "folder tab" uses 128 px by 128px just like anyother image. This is not a major problem but it is not ideal since it robs additional space that could be used by another icon. The standard image used for this button from Stardock is a Plus Sign and a Minus sign which are esthetically too large giving a gaudy appearance. Shrinking this image to a smaller size is something I recommend but it still will take 128x128px

Having said all these things I believe this to be the best dock in terms of usage if one thinks beyond emulating a Mac dock and places usability and practicallity as the major function. If all you need is a dock with 10 or fewer icons then any of the other Mac-like docks will be great but if one needs to use 20-30 icons then Objectdock Plus is king. While many plug-ins or docklets exist for other docks enhamcing the user experience most is eye candy when one considers that the primary function of a dock is launching folders and applications.

I would like to see other people making suggestions to improve ths dock in a constructive way or get people to offer a similar capability on the other FREE docks.

#206344

The way I like to do it is have a non tabbed dock as my tasks\file manager launch\tash can and tabbed docks to launch my programs. Which is how some people on the mac do it with the regular dock + dragthing which has been available since OS9. So since there is dragthing for the mac it isn't a stretch or really going against the mac grain to have tabbed docks.

#206348

could i get PNGs of those custom plus and minus icons?

#207375

Good feedback. Will talk to jeff and see what we can do.

#207849

One thing I don't get is why the option for flyout menus aren't in the expanding dock? It's a pain, well sometimes, to make a flyout on a tabbed dock, then drag it to the ordinary dock. If you don't have a tabbed dock already, thats the hassle.

I'm guessing Jeff builds both updates to the Plus and Free versions, then just exports one half the dock? So adding Flyout shortcuts would be a pain for him?

Otherwise, great app for me.

#207871

Septimus, the option to add a flyout to a zoomer is there, you just have to be careful where you click (yes, not very obvious I know). Don't try it near a separator, try on the very end of the dock, it does work.

#207874

will tabbed docks ever be able to zoom? i can`t get used to the icons sitting still :P

#207883

Ahhhh... odd, but thanks :)

#207890

KICKASS ! :)

#207960

Federation, I liked the custom plus/minus icon you have there. I bashed out a couple of very similar looking ones for an OD+ theme of mine, would you have any problems with me re-releasing the theme with these included? If they aren't yours, do you have any idea who did them so I might ask?

pic: minus.jpg

[edit] typo, my bad

#207977

Originally posted by Unbeliever@Aug 27 2004, 02:20 AM

will tabbed docks ever be able to zoom? i can`t get used to the icons sitting still :P

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Probably not as it would make things weird when having more than one row of icons. ;)

#208028