[link] Why Flash Is Evil....

Flash is Evil....

Must I say more...

Well yes..I do not agree. just wanted to share. Maybe some people here that use and love flash. I sent the guy an e-mail..what I said can not be repeated here... :D

Anyway he claims he read rumors of flash repleacing html...well iI disagree. Flash needs html if you want to launch your site at a certain size..witch also uses java script. Well if and when Action Script 3 comes out if that is possible then maybe JUST MABE there will be a smaller need for html. Still most people use html and flash simply because of bandwith and ease of updating...

BTW, the guy is a ****ing lunatic...and I know that the site is old. But I didn't see it here so...there ya go! :P

#190230

Reading that got me off my ass to install a flash-blocker... finally. For OS X: PithHelmet is the bee's knees. Screenshots here. Ah... no more distracting ads with my newspaper, my webmail, nothing. The net almost seems naked now. Just hope this doesn't come back to haunt me later.

#190247

The chance of flash replacing HTML is possible as browsers can be modified to read straight .SWF files.

It will just never happen this early in the internet's life span because Flash is still an expensive (but nice) commercial product and therefore the chance of it being choosen as a standard by the W3C is small.

When anyone can develop high-quality flash movies with a free program, maybe it will happen but I don't see this happening for a few years still.

#190251

Oh well....

Flash is a tool, just like a knife. You can cut bread with it, or your finger. And if you want to blame someone, blame the one who cuts your finger because of ignorance, stupidity or whatever, not the knife.

Flash content can be animated or static, resizable or fixed, fast or slow, light, heavy, whatever you want it to be. If it's used in annoying ads in a page you read, that is the advertiser's fault, or the page author's who let such ads appear on his site.

I've been using Flash since version 2, and I could spend pages writing about it, so I stop while it's still early.

Have a nice day!

Ken™

#190257

Flash is evil...

But the guy who wrote that has no real understanding of why. Like one person said, he's basically heard someone smart explain why Flash is a pain in the arse, and has taken their arguments and diluted them in such a way as to lose the original message, which was likely something to the effect of "Flash, when done wrong or too much, is an awful thing. When done right, and sparingly, it's a good medium for particular applications."

No-one who knows anything sensible about the web really thinks Flash is the future, or that it's pure evil. The key is in moderation, as with most things in life. There are places where Flash has been done right. Again, it's all a matter of doing things in moderation, and with good justification.

"We're a genuinely funny web cartoon, unlike most of the other tripe on the web that tries (and fails) at being funny".

"We want to have animated illustrations of [x], so that we can teach people in a more efficient way".

"We're professional web designers and know what we're doing with Flash, what it's problems are, and we can make a very good case for our pointed use of them, thankyou very much".

These are all very good reasons, because they involve an innate understanding of the medium in which the designer is working. "I can make cool animations that people will see and think "wow, this guy/girl is really cool"", however, is not.

#190260

flash is boring.

so's webdesign. Its just gotta be nice enough to be unobtrusive.

i want content.

#190277

It's totally a question of what you use it for. Most entertainment-based websites (bands, video games, etc.) would be totally boring with strict html/css and no flash. Some of the best sites I've seen are strictly flash and they work. Not every person browsing the web is just looking at blogs and text. I agree, it's all in the application.

#190290

Originally posted by johnny5w@Jul 16 2004, 10:54 AM

It's totally a question of what you use it for. Most entertainment-based websites (bands, video games, etc.) would be totally boring with strict html/css and no flash. [...]

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Oh, really?

#190306

I stand by my statement. It's 2004.

#190307

That doesn't make any sense. There are awesome sites made in Flash, and awful ones. Same for plain HTML sites. Flash doesn't make you a better designer, it just gives you features to play with: vector graphics, lightweight animation, interactivity, etc. You don't necessariy need all those in order to build a good site.

#190308

Exactly, Ken.

For what it's worth, johnny5w, that site was made last year by silverorange, a world-renowned, and critically aclaimed web development and design house.

Just because it's 2004 doesn't mean that 2003, 2002, and so forth's techniques are any less valid, it just means that we should use them in the correct context.

Also, who needs Flash for vector graphics and animation?

Give me SVG any day :P

#190312

By the way, it would be much better if sloanmusic.com samples were in mp3 or flash ( :P ) instead of realaudio.

#190313

Originally posted by Ken@Jul 16 2004, 01:09 PM

By the way, it would be much better if sloanmusic.com samples were in mp3 or flash ( :P ) instead of realaudio.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

What other pure audio/video streaming formats are supported by Apache? -_-

#190318

www.2advanced.com is a good flash site. I like it anyway.

#190324

not anywhere near as good as orisinal.org though. If that isn't an example of a good use of flash I don't know what is.

#190335

Well this is more complex than I thought... :(

Some of the resons that wee disscused in the flash is evil site is why RAD.E8 left flash and went stickly to htmll...Ease of use wasn't one of those resons in my opinion. a full html site of a site with more html and just flash animations.. are a lot easier to update in my opinion. Then agian I have been wrong many times before. >.<

Even the ****iest flash site like mine..can be found HERE.... is really not that bad. I took into consideration some of the mistakes others have made and tried to find a solution. One of witch was to use different html pages to put each flash movie in. rather than making a huge one with a loading screen. And flash can also be used for VERY VERY GOOD RESONS....found here..To educate others and found HERE to mave fun interactive movies.. AND some times pretty but anyoing sites like this one here that have so much LOOONG flash movies brwosing the site becomes very anyoing..I still have much to learn as I am redoing my site agian and reading that made me redsign the layout.. >.<

#190415

@ Stevie-

I think you and I will just have a difference of opinion on design with flash. My comment wasn't to mean "It's 2004: all good web sites must use flash." I think we all agree that's ridiculous. I was commenting on the design of that site. [valley girl]It's so 5 years ago.[/valley girl] As a band site it's just bland and boring, world renowned and critically acclaimed design or not. But like I say, that's a style issue, and I don't think we'll agree on that.

#190458

Originally posted by johnny5w@Jul 16 2004, 08:18 PM

@ Stevie-

I think you and I will just have a difference of opinion on design with flash. My comment wasn't to mean "It's 2004: all good web sites must use flash." I think we all agree that's ridiculous. I was commenting on the design of that site.  [valley girl]It's so 5 years ago.[/valley girl]  As a band site it's just bland and boring, world renowned and critically acclaimed design or not. But like I say, that's a style issue, and I don't think we'll agree on that.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

That's my main argument, though - you seem to be under the impression that Flash=good design, HTML/CSS=poor design.

There are many, many more real artists and designers who use XHTML and CSS2 and create good, well designed web sites than there are those who create them with (purely) Flash.

If you want to see what can really be done with XHTML and CSS2, take a walk in the garden...

#190489

At least this thread brought some links to very interesting sites, flashy or not.

... with Stevie being the best site digger of all ;)

#190563

@Stevie-

No, I'm not under that impression. I've been to the garden (tra la la!) and I love a lot of the stuff that's up. I think they have some great ideas, and it's cool how they integrate. But I insist that for a majority of entertainment-based websites (not blogs or companies selling stuff) flash adds a dimension not reachable by xhtml/css2. You can just do more with it visually. That's what a lot of people (maybe not you, that's fine) care about. Different strokes for different folks.

I think it's best if maybe we just agree to disagree. :P

#190565

Originally posted by johnny5w@Jul 17 2004, 01:07 AM

@Stevie-

No, I'm not under that impression. I've been to the garden (tra la la!) and I love a lot of the stuff that's up. I think they have some great ideas, and it's cool how they integrate. But I insist that for a majority of entertainment-based websites (not blogs or companies selling stuff) flash adds a dimension not reachable by xhtml/css2. You can just do more with it visually. That's what a lot of people (maybe not you, that's fine) care about. Different strokes for different folks.

I think it's best if maybe we just agree to disagree.  :P

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Ah, okay... I didn't get the entertainment-based part of your view.

I do agree that it can, often add a dinemsion of interactivity and interest not possible in XHTML/CSS2, but I would suggest that this isn't always the case, depending on the medium. :)

To be honest, I don't think we need to agree to disagree - I think we've actually got rather similar views, in most respects :P

#190718

Well.......you guys no way more than me about ANYTHING!!!!! >.-_-:rolleyes:

All I know is html, a little java, and well I can EDIT css (I did for me forums here CLICK IT DAMN IT....

#192292

The reason i hate Flash is because it saves huge files, which even take ages to load on my 512kbps connection. :(

#196714