The Best IPod Generation

Eh, I'm bored and thought it would be a nice little discussion.

1st & 2nd Gen

  • Scrolling/Touch sensitive dial
  • Four buttons around the dial
  • Rounded back corners, and flat face
  • Firewire plug at the top
  • No dock
  • Breakout
  • No button lights

3rd Gen

  • Touch sensitive dial
  • Four touch sensitive buttons aligned at the top
  • More rounded
  • Literally no moving parts
  • Connector at the bottom to dock or Firewire
  • Breakout, Solitare and Parachutes
  • Glowing orange button lights

This is not a topic to talk about the rumors for the 4th Gen iPods.

#181050

in terms of design, the first and second are far more interesting, and i'm not all that keen on the chrome on the back of the 3rd gen iPod. I think that they hsould return to having the buttons round the dial, but obviously now with newer technology they ccan still keep it nice and small.

#181052

Originally posted by board4britain+Jun 23 2004, 02:43 PM-->
QUOTE(board4britain @ Jun 23 2004, 02:43 PM)
in terms of design, the first and second are far more interesting, and i'm not all that keen on the chrome on the back of the 3rd gen iPod.
Both the 2nd and 3rd gen have teh chrome (1st gen was before my time) (or did I terribly misinterpret you?)

#181054

i can`t say which one i like better in terms of aesthetics. Both have their pros and cons, however i like everything else except the battery on 3rd Gen.

/hugs his 15gigger :P

#181072

Originally posted by Keith@Jun 23 2004, 12:45 PM

Both the 2nd and 3rd gen have teh chrome (1st gen was before my time) (or did I terribly misinterpret you?)

All gens had the chrome back.

The 1st and 2nd gens where basically the same. The only major difference was that the First gens had a scrolling dial. The second generation had a touch scroll.

And also the Breakout game was an easter egg on the 1st gens.

I don't think there were enough differences to split them.

#181085

I like certain features of all the generations... Like the more flat front of the 1st and 2nd Gens.. But I like the un-raised buttons of the 3G ones (the raised surrounding buttons doesn't look as nice to me).

So it would be a draw.. But 3Gs have more space for my :P:lol:

#181136