Tough Call Btwn Obj & Y's Dock

It's getting to be a tough call between Objectdock and Y's dock.

Objecdock continues to be faster with more options of configuration, but Y's dock is no slouch either. Y's dock scrolls very smoothly. There is a point that a faster dock has no meaning if the effect transition smoothly and does not lag your hand movements.

The major pluses that I see for each dock are as follows:

Y's Dock

1. Good stability overall with hide feature

2. Good implementation of Trash Can (Rubbish you say?)

3.Good pop-up folder feature (maybe the response time should be cut to 75% of the present=25% faster) with no configuration needed.

4. Good and promising plug-in=docklet feature

5. Responsive one-click launch application/folder/web site

Objectdock

1. Fast and smooth with various magnifying configurations

2. Good drag & drop icon configuration better implemented than Y's dock

3. Easier to get to configuration menu (with PNG icon rather than searching for a slim dividing line

4. Dock resizes better to screen width

--------------------------------

Problems that still need to be addressed:

Y's dock Cons:

Major

1. Clock hands are too long for practically all PNG clocks made

2. Icon assignment window sometimes will not display all icons or are not alphabetical..

Minor

3. Ys dock interferes more than any of the other docks with the graphics on a game

4. A Dock configuration icon is the easiest way to get to configurations

5. Decrease the reaction time to list pop-up folders

6. Needs a better explanation on how to configure apps. (Links, Arguments, Work folder= what the hell is all this?) . By now every dock Y's, Mobydock,Objecdock should have a list of commonly configurable items in an illustrated PDF file. Newcomers should no longer need to be asking 100 questions of how to link My Computer, or whatever.

Objectdock Cons:

Major

1. Still unreliable one-click response

2. No pop-up folder implementation

3. Z-order, or what is on top not well implemented

Minor

1. Suggestion:Configuration Window is at the limit of height and any further options should be planned on widening the Configuration Window

Once Mobydock releases his dock it may be time for another Poll.

#14628

Well I agree wth some of the things that you have listed but not all.

1) Configurating Y'z is extremely easy. You don't have to search for the divider line. Just right click near where it is. If you have stuff on the left and right side it should be no problem and if you do have a problem then it's you, not the dock.

2) The reaction time for folders is mainly machine dependent I'm guessing, because they pop-up with no delay on my system.

3) The drag and drop in Y'z is very easy. I haven't had to mess with arguments or work folder yet. I just drag programs off of the Start Menu to the dock, change the icon and viola, it's done (with the minor exception of Office XP which doesn't work when dragged off of the dock, has to be done from the Office folder).

4) Right clicking the bin allows an easy way to empty the bin.

5) Y'z doesn't have to be installed. Just keep it any a folder any place you want and run it. No need to worry about installing or uninstalling (just delete the folder).

6) Includes Benchmark support build in.

7) Supports Auto-hide delay

8) One other thing I particularly like is that Y'z has no icons or shortcuts included when installed. You decide what you want and what icon you want, instead of a whole bunch of icons/links appearing that you'll end up changing or dragging off of the dock anyway.

9) You can right click on the dock icons in Y'z and still get regular Right-click context menus as if it were a regular desktop icon.

10) ObjectDock configuration menu is very, very cluttered and confusing. Y'z is sweet and simple.

Y'z Dock - 897kb

ObjectDock - 3.33mb

#14631

Well, for me Im loving Yz's dock so far. working perfect for me.

#14632

I have been using YZ's Dock since the first version and love it. It runs so smoothly and quickly on my computer. The zoom of the dock may not be the most accurate compared to OSX (although from my limited experience it appears to be the closest thing to the real thing) it is my favorite zoom as none of the icons are degraded while zooming. Each version keeps getting better. I can't wait for YZ to realease the SDK for the dock plug-ins. All I need right now to make it my ideal dock is some more plug-ins, ideally a weather one that has been suggested several times before by many people on various forums. Not only would that look awesome, it would be really functional as it is a pain to have to open up your browser every morning to find out whether or not to take the umbrella or wear an extra layer of clothing. I got around this a little bit by using aim alearts delivered to me at 8:00 am and 5:00 pm, but its nowhere nearly as cool or as useful as having it in the dock constantly being updated.

To be completely honest like every major revolution in computing I initally thought of it as a gimick (Who would want to listen to music on their computer or take pictures with a digital camera) but have since come around and discovered how useful it is. Once the SDK comes, the possibilities are going to be endless for what it can do, just look at what the mac communty.

Mac OS X Docklets

Its amazing what people have done. When they say OS X is a living OS, they aren't kidding. The Dock is far from a quicklaunch bar / taskbar, it does so many things, and now we will get the opportunity to do some of those thigns on our pcs.

#14653

The possibility of Dock plug-ins (docklets) is endless. I would love an iCal docklet, (to go with an iCal clone, hint, hint) changing the *.png each corresponding day. :) The Trash has 2 png changestates, so in theory, why couldn't a docklet have up to 31? Sounds a bit slow but it wouldn't render them as 31. It would still do 1 at a time, it would prolly decrease Y'zdock loadup times though...

Oh yeh, I like Y'z dock. :D

Cheers

*Think Y'z.*

#14657

Flyakite:

If you have stuff on the left and right side it should be no problem and if you do have a problem then it's you, not the dock.

Hey! don't be stupid and make comments as personal attacks. Yes stupid is meant to be a personal comment on your description of "problem" . If you read carefully you see that I'm commenting on my opinion to shortcomings regarding the docks or better implementations and not saying they are personal problems. Get smart will you! I'm glad you agree with some points and added your own evaluation but choose your words better if you don't like people to flame you either. Maybe you have a problem? Get real, it's a piece of software I'm talking about not your mother or wife.

#14678

I have no problems with the clock hands and the clock PNG that I'm using :)

clock.jpg

I didn't make it, and I'm not taking any credit for it, but here it is if you want it:

Clock02.png

(Right click on it and goto Save As.. ;) )

#14680

Hi all, I'm a new Y'z Dock's user and I found it's great, but I have a question:

does Y'zDock have a taskbar like MobyDock or ObjectDock have too? :o

If yes, how can I do to activate it ??

Sorry, for English

Tankz to all :D

#14682

A major con for Objectdock for me is if the task view is on, OD will crash every time I close Outlook2002 and it'll also randomly crash if a PopUpStopper is active and prohibiting IE windows from popping up.

I have never had Yz dock lock up on me...(yet)...I used to use Yz on my work machine (because I use Outlook) and OD on my home machine (don't use Outlook at home)...this new version of Yz made me switch my home machine to Yz too. I do miss the task view, but the popup folders and other goodies won me over.

#14695

First of all VideoMann I have nothing against you or anyone else here. All I was doing was adding some points that I felt needed mentioning as well. When I said "If you have stuff on the left and right side it should be no problem and if you do have a problem then it's you, not the dock.", I didn't mean you personally, I meant people in general. And not in a bad way either, just that if you can't seem to access the config. menu easily then there is probably something that you're just not doing right. If you have a problem getting to it I don't think you're stupid, I just think there is something you're not quite doing correctly.

Sorry for any confusion,

~Flyakite

#14702

flyakite

Thanks for your clarification.

I just think there is something you're not quite doing correctly.

I like to say that, I'm not doing anything wrong in regards to getting to the configuration window. I can get it to it all the time. I'm just saying that having an icon is a better way and faster way to get to that dialog window. It is easier to see, more intuitive, and faster in most cases. That icon can be a direct launcher to a configuration window or it can also have a right-click configuration menu just as the trashcan has.

This is why I said an icon is a better implementation to get to this featre. Some people don't like it not based on the reasons that I stated but based that it is not how the original Mac dock does it. In that case the argument becomes one based on taste rather than functionality and intuitiveness. The choice is ultimately the individual user, but overall to me the choice should be made on functionality and intuitiveness over style or looks in most cases.

It goes to the heart of the philosophical reason: Are we cloning Mac apps to the point of cloning not only its looks and behavior but also its shortcomings? ... or are we to clone Mac apps. being mindful that some minor changes could lead to improvements either in functionality, looks, or intuitiveness? I see people on both sides of this argument to me the choice is obvious. I want a better app whenever possible than the original (not neccessarily a perfect clone). That improvement could come in many forms small or large (ex. more flexibility in looks, more flexibility in functionality, easier to understand). I'm very pleased with both docks Ys and OD and Mobydock may be very good when it gets released and some of its bugs are workedout. It is not a matter of trashing one dock over another but just expressing some issues that could be improved.

RealyPssd

Thanks for the clock picture you posted , but I know the hands look O.K. on the "default" clock but my point is that one should not use the default Mac clock as the model to decide the thickness and length of the "clock hands". The hands are too long on practically all other clocks made by users (over 10-12 clocks). Just as Ys dock latest version has clock hands that are too long, Objectdock has clock hands that are too thin, so my criticism is not based on personal likeness of Ys versus ObjDock but based on looks and function.

This picture was posted earlier on another thread to illustrate my point. It may or may not show-up from time to time depending on the bandwidth usage.

ProblemClock.jpg

The only temporary solution is to use the default clock you posted, the long term solution is to shorten all the clock hands. The clock icon PNGs can not be adjusted to accomodate the long hands in most cases.

Thanks again for your post Flyakite and for your re-post of the icon RealyPssd

#14812