It's getting to be a tough call between Objectdock and Y's dock.
Objecdock continues to be faster with more options of configuration, but Y's dock is no slouch either. Y's dock scrolls very smoothly. There is a point that a faster dock has no meaning if the effect transition smoothly and does not lag your hand movements.
The major pluses that I see for each dock are as follows:
Y's Dock
1. Good stability overall with hide feature
2. Good implementation of Trash Can (Rubbish you say?)
3.Good pop-up folder feature (maybe the response time should be cut to 75% of the present=25% faster) with no configuration needed.
4. Good and promising plug-in=docklet feature
5. Responsive one-click launch application/folder/web site
Objectdock
1. Fast and smooth with various magnifying configurations
2. Good drag & drop icon configuration better implemented than Y's dock
3. Easier to get to configuration menu (with PNG icon rather than searching for a slim dividing line
4. Dock resizes better to screen width
--------------------------------
Problems that still need to be addressed:
Y's dock Cons:
Major
1. Clock hands are too long for practically all PNG clocks made
2. Icon assignment window sometimes will not display all icons or are not alphabetical..
Minor
3. Ys dock interferes more than any of the other docks with the graphics on a game
4. A Dock configuration icon is the easiest way to get to configurations
5. Decrease the reaction time to list pop-up folders
6. Needs a better explanation on how to configure apps. (Links, Arguments, Work folder= what the hell is all this?) . By now every dock Y's, Mobydock,Objecdock should have a list of commonly configurable items in an illustrated PDF file. Newcomers should no longer need to be asking 100 questions of how to link My Computer, or whatever.
Objectdock Cons:
Major
1. Still unreliable one-click response
2. No pop-up folder implementation
3. Z-order, or what is on top not well implemented
Minor
1. Suggestion:Configuration Window is at the limit of height and any further options should be planned on widening the Configuration Window
Once Mobydock releases his dock it may be time for another Poll.
Aqua-Soft Forums

