Posted 28 November 2002 - 02:38 PM
Brian4ever - Nice skin. However, you appear to have made some oversights,
Oversight No1.
You appear to have erased all information about the origin of "your" skin in the Skinfamily.ini file. In case you don't know, this file holds, amongst other things, the information that is displayed within QCD about a skin, it's origin, it's list of revisions and what has been changed. It is commonly used to hold the information from the creator of the skin.
I can't help noticing that you removed all reference to myself, the list of changes throughout the history of this skin and all reference to GameBoyzGB who originally created this skin. Now GameBoyzGB is a very decent chap and I have the greatest respect for him and his work. So I asked his permission to modify his skin and being such a decent chap he said yes.
To your credit you did embed a notes.txt file (not part of the QCD spec) within the .qsf file that reads "I have to give credit to SpidercrabX and GameboyzGB for this skin. They supplied the basic material". For anyone who chooses to dig into the .qsf file, it is there, loud and clear. I, and I am sure GameBoyzGB, are honoured to consider the many hours that both of us put into this skin to be up to your standards of "basic material".
Oversight No 2.
You appear to have named the skin with exactly the same name as my skin. What are the chances of that happening in a random world? This may get a little confusing for those people expecting to use my skin and they get yours instead. Especially when you have modified the skin to deviate from the real iTunes appearance.
Oversight No 3.
You appear to have named the QCD file with exactly the same name I used! So anyone who downloads "your" skin would overwrite and delete my skin. It is customary to use a name that is not already used so
as to avoid complication, confusion and disappointment.
Hint: Both the names iTunes3 and iTunes3.qsf are already used.
You might like to make amends so as to maintain some degree of credibility. There are too many people out there doing a quick "cut and shunt" on bitmap based skins these days. You wouldn't want to be confused with one of those, would you.
By the way, what exactly were the "lot of graphical errors in this skin: pixel adjustment, colors, etc" that you fixed?
To all others:
QCD does NOT support shadows. There are no shadows available with any skin for QCD. You cannot provide a shadow on the iTunes3 skin.